Synthetic Insulated Jackets

[AJTG]

Hi all,

I'm currently trying to decide between the following jackets:

Rab Generator Alpine, Montane Ice Guide, Mountain Equipment Fitzroy, Berghaus Ignite Hoody.

Does anyone have any experience of the differences between these? I'm looking for a jacket that will keep me warm when stationary in wind and rain, but still packs down nicely.

I think the warmest one would be the Ice Guide, but might it not be so wind/water-proof?

Any comments would be really appreciated.

Thanks

[murwilson]

Deja vu ?

I'm sure I responded to this in a different forum.

I've been drinking though, so may have dreamt that

Mur