kinley wrote:Personally, if I was on a MTB I'd cycle from the west end of Loch Morlich up past Rothiemurchus Lodge.
I've walked out this way - this starts at 320m the Sugar Bowl is 460m. But you have to go through Chalamain from Sugar Bowl and drop 100m to the Lairig which negates the minor height advantage. It's only about 1.4km further from Morlich - with no Chalamain Gap boulders.
I've never been quite sure why the Sugar Bowl-Chalamain route is popular.
That's a good suggestion, I was on that path again a few weeks ago and it's much easier overall than Chalamain Gap. The return back to the car would be pretty much downhill all the way.
I think the poularity of routes is very dependent on whatever is written in guide books and outdoor magazines and the Chalamain Gap is the route opted for in many publications. I have to admit to following guide books for quite a few years, but eventually I became confident enough to decide for myself which route to take. I reckon if Trail or TGO recommended starting at say Loch an Eilean and going by Glen Einich as the preferred route to Braeriach, rather than from Sugar Bowl, enough walkers would religiously follow that route to make it popular. It is a better route in my opinion.
I also believe that big estates influence walkers with the information boards and maps they produce, recommending certain routes to hills, to manage the flow of human traffic around the estate.