canisp wrote:I’d agree with you 100%…… but its all in the wording, people never say i’m summiting the Munro’s/Corbetts or Grahams or reaching the top of the Munro’s, they usually say i’m doing, bagging or climbing the Munro’s and these words are open to interpretation. I’d agree you can’t summit a hill without reaching the summit but i don’t believe you have to reach/touch the summit to claim a mountain as done/bagged or climbed, whether or not you tick the hill as done in your logger is down to your own conscience and any rules of the site.
I know, but under my own conscience I wouldn't class a hill as done, bagged, summited, or anything else unless you'd been to the very highest point.
My original point was the WH description lists the hill under the "Summits Climbed" section of the walk description. As Paul mentioned, it makes sense of sorts to have a link to the walk description from the hills own general page, albeit you don't summit it for real. Perhaps there's a need to have a different kind of link like "Hills walked on but not summited"
I wonder how heated the debate about this would be if it were a Munro....