by Mal Grey » Sat Jan 16, 2021 8:50 pm
I used to sell these, or something almost identical, over 30 years ago in the YHA shop in Nottingham. Never tried them out though.
My memory is that they seemed OK as a dog walking, gardening, general pottering about boot, but lacked the structure of a proper walking boot (a bit bendy). They also had a very soft, and fairly shallow, tread pattern which doesn't look to have changed at all. It looked OK grip-wise, but felt like it wouldn't last long on harder surfaces.
If they're for general dog walking on softer terrains, especially wet environments and muddy stuff, they might work well. For hillwalking I don't think they'd have the support, or the sole last. I also assume they're horrible in warm weather, but have no evidence for that from actual experience, other than the fact they're completely non-breathable and have a thickish lining.
The main reason we stocked them was that they weren't leather, but none of us liked advising people to go hillwalking in them.