by SpaceCaptainTheodore » Wed Mar 22, 2017 10:14 pm
It isn't clear to me that the request was for a winter tent. For what it's worth, the Banshee and the Tempest are quite popular and represent good value and are appropriate for three season use. The Salewa tent is probably similar. I haven't used any of these tents but would offer the following perspectives:
Side entry makes for easy tea brewing in a porch, favouring the banshee and micro over the tempest
Tunnel tents are pretty robust and, once inside, offer decent all around space, favouring the tempest over the others
Tunnel tents can also be a bugger to pitch well on uneven ground (for me anyway, though I may just be incompetent or unlucky), favouring the banshee and micro over the tempest
Most will be perfectly able to carry any of these happily, but it's always worth getting the weight down if the cost penalty isn't too great, this favours the banshee and the micro over the tempest
Overall, that'd edge me toward the Banshee. At this end of the price range, I'd also take a wee look at the Coleman Cobra which is a very (almost suspiciously) similar tent to the Banshee but cheaper. If you're just dipping your toe in the water it might be worth a look and it's a tent I'd happily take out on most of trips I take.
Like anything, your tent is a trade off of all sorts of factors: space, weight, quality of the light shining through, room for wet kit, resilience to wind, rain and bog, ease of fitting into its bag, ease of pitching etc. So, if you can, try and get to see one in a shop; any of these will do for general use and if you know you like how it looks and feels you'll have got at least one thing right!