by Sack the Juggler » Wed Sep 19, 2018 11:19 am
I use Meindl boots, but I'm sure either of the ones you've mentioned will do the job, the key thing about boots is the fit.
I have a wide forefoot, a narrow ankle and a wide calf, so getting boots to fit is a nightmare, and usually involves some trick lacing skills, however some people have narrow feet, wide feet, average feet, etc, and different boots (even by the same manufacturer) will be made with a different shaped last, so its best to go and try them on, and keep trying them on until you find a boot that is perfect for you.
Some of the larger outdoors companies have decent boot fitters that will help you choose a boot that will fit your foot and your purpose, so try to find a few near you.
If you shout out where you are then others on here might be able to recommend some?