walkhighlands

Share your personal walking route experiences in Scotland, and comment on other peoples' reports.
Warning Please note that hillwalking when there is snow lying requires an ice-axe, crampons and the knowledge, experience and skill to use them correctly. Summer routes may not be viable or appropriate in winter. See winter information on our skills and safety pages for more information.

Meall Doire Faid Revisited

Meall Doire Faid Revisited


Postby Yorjick » Sun Aug 08, 2021 10:58 am

Fionas included on this walk: Meall Doire Faid

Date walked: 22/07/2021

Time taken: 6 hours

Distance: 11 km

Ascent: 800m

2 people think this report is great.
Register or Login
free to be able to rate and comment on reports (as well as access 1:25000 mapping).

IMGP3546_stitch_banner.jpg


I first attempted this route on January 4th of this year. There was deep snow all the way down to the road. The day started badly with me getting my car stuck at the parking place (see notes above). Placing car mats behind the front wheels, I eventually managed to reverse back out.

This resulted in a slightly later than planned start, especially as I had to park a mile up the road and walk back. The going was hard right from the road with knee deep snow and no existing footprints to follow. Also, I was feeling a little below par and this was my first hill for a year, having spent the preceding year in Kazakhstan without travelling home due to the pandemic.

I had done a lot of cycling over the summer but it is hard staying fit over the long, cold winters.

I had hoped that it would be more wind swept higher up but the snow remained soft and deep. There was a party on skis over to my left and I felt that they were making slightly better progress than I. I wondered if snowshoes would make a difference or if the snow was so soft that they would pile up with snow.

I eventually met up with the skiers where there is a bit of a gully coinciding with a a levelling out or slight dip in the ridge. The skiers told me that they could be down in 15 minutes! Somehow, I thought it would take me a bit longer. The route ahead seemed extremely steep. The snow was banked up, almost creating a cornice. It was extremely hard work overcoming this section with my feet penetrating to the bottom of the snow to the rocks below. Crampons would not have helped at all. The snow was not really firm enough to place my axe shaft in the snow above and pull. After a lot of struggling, I made it to slightly easier ground above, but it had sapped my energies and I was breathing hard.

I continued along the ridge, but eventually had to stop. I really was not feeling very well. I pushed on a little bit further with the summit in sight, but on reaching the point from which the photograph below was taken, I made the decision to drop down directly to the road and return another day. The snow seemed even deeper on the southern slopes and I was not feeling any better. After a while I stopped to drink some hot coffee, but it did not stay down. Further down, my left leg sunk into a snowy hole. I tried to pull it out but all the pulling and twisting did was stain my groin. I momentarily thought to myself, "Is this how it all ends?". Digging snow out with my hands and more pulling and twisting, I was eventually able to extract my leg and I proceeded downwards with greater care. Progress was slow considering I was walking downhill and it was getting dark by the time I reached the A835. I started the march back to my car. I decided to not to try and hitch a lift due to the pandemic, but a nice couple stopped anyway. If I remember correctly, they had been up Cul Mhor or Cul Beag and apparently the walking conditions were good without such deep snow. They informed me that they were not concerned about Coronavirus so I gratefully jumped in for the 5km back to my car.

It took be three attempts to reach Geal Chàrn, in the Monadhliath. The first time was because we could not cross the Markie Burn due to heavy rain and the second time I tried to ascend it on very narrow cross-country skis in strong winds. The skis were not really suitable for ski mountaineering and besides which, the entire group decided to turn back. I have returned to do it twice since then, so the score is 2-2.

​I also turned back from Beinn a'Chochuill and Beinn Eunaich due to an upset stomach. That turned out to be the right decision. That was low down on the track.

I also remember turning back at the rock band high up on Liathach due to high winds, with just one of our party of four continuing.

My climbing partner and I also once backed off a climbing route on Tryfan in continuous rain, though I was happy to continue on that occasion. We wore walking socks on the outside of our rock boots.

I have never been "beaten" by a Corbett and I never thought that I would fail to reach the top of a Graham, especially one so close to the road and with quite a high starting point

IMGP3557.jpg



our_route.gpx Open full screen  NB: Walkhighlands is not responsible for the accuracy of gpx files in users posts



I would ordinarily have returned sooner, but working overseas, this was my first opportunity after my 10 day quarantine. The weather had been glorious and it was a tad frustrating being stuck at home, but at least I got a few jobs done and practiced a bit of macro photography.

I drove to the parking place where I had become stuck six months earlier. There were a few overnighting camper vans and it was hard to believe that I had such difficulty on an old section A road. Looking east there was a lot of cloud that I knew would soon "burn off" (seems like a strange term as water vapour does not actually burn). Looking west, there were blue skies and clear tops to the mountains. My objective still had a bit of cloud on the summit.

IMGP9017.jpg


Looking west towards An Teallach:

IMGP9022.jpg


Just over three years ago, I bought my first DSLR and for today a recently acquired second hand but mint condition 35mm macro lens was attached. Half of my six lenses are weather sealed but this is not one of them. I left my trusty 20-40mm WR lens at home, confident that it would not rain. If I wanted something wider, I could stitch photos for a panorama and I could make use of the macro capabilities of the 35mm lens for flowers and bugs.

​Below: spotted orchid, Dactylorhiza fuchsii.

IMGP9026.jpg


Bog asphodel, Narthecium ossifragum.

IMGP9035.jpg


Heather, Calluna vulgaris.

IMGP9045.jpg


The lens still works well for landscapes: The Fannichs.

IMGP9049.jpg


Screenshot 2021-08-07 11.21.jpg


...And a more panoramic view from stitched photos.

IMGP9058_stitch.jpg


Looking towards the Fisherfield Forest and An Teallach.

IMGP9075_stitch.jpg


There is no such thing as a boring hill. Every Scottish hill is full of natural beauty.

IMGP9083.jpg


IMGP9085.jpg


IMGP9090.jpg


There was still a lot of cloud to the east. My route was to bass over the hill to the left, but I was confident that it would clear by then.

IMGP9091-2.jpg


It is hard to believe that the upper part of this section had caused me such difficulties but the snow had settled in a way to make it steeper than it appears here.

IMGP9093.jpg


Moving onwards and upwards, within one of the slight dips, I saw a rusty colouration on the ground. I really could not make out what it was until I closed in on it and saw that it was a cannister that was used as a flare. Normally, I would remove such things from the hill but I still had a long way to go to carry it in my hand and I did not want it to contaminate my kit in my backpack. Perhaps it was from a parallel universe, where I had not made the decision to head down in January? I was certainly curious as to whether it was from some sort of military exercise or a rescue.

IMGP9097.jpg


Looking towards Beinn Dearg rising up above the patchy clouds.

IMGP9098.jpg


I posted the flower below on the NHM UK Biodiversity Facebook page. Usually, I get a definitive answer, but on this occasions, I received several suggestions as to shat it might be:

David Feld
"Hieracium, sp."

Peter Coleman-Smith
"No, it’s a mountain lion"

Belinda Durrant
"Some sort of hawkweed??"
"Which is as it turns out Hieracium sp as David Feld said 🙄"

Andy Temple
"Autumnal Hawkbit"

Annie Chow
"It's cat's ear"

Susan Lane
"Looks to me very much like the hawkweed growing in my garden south of Oxford. Correction, this particular plant is the Long-rooted Cat's Ear, similar flower to the Hawkweed, but the leaves are different."

Caitríona Michelle
"False dandelion:
Hypochaeris radicata, also known as catsear, flatweed, cat's-ear, and hairy cat's ear, is a perennial, low-lying edible herb often found in lawns."

Richard Collingridge
"I don't think we can really see enough to say much more than that it's not one of the many actual dandelions (Taraxicum spp), as those have fleshy stems, without the hairs and bracts (tiny leaves) which are visible here.
We really need to see the leaves and the whole stem, and ideally the heads before and after flowering. There are quite a few of these "dandeloids" and they can be tricky to tell apart without close examination, often needing a lens and a key.
I'm not going to stick my neck out with a guess..."
"Interestingly almost all UK plants with dandelion-type flowers have English names with animals in them, or animal parts, or both (hawkbit, hawksbeard, oxtongue, catsear etc etc). Dandelion itself, which is from the French for "lion's tooth" (dent de lion)."

​Richard is of course right in that I should have included details of the leaves and stems. As a photographer, my interest is in the beauty of the flower, but as a biologist, I should understand the importance of all parts of the plant when identifying the species.

IMGP9123.jpg


This photograph was taken not for its topographical interest, but because it approximated to the point at which I had retreated off the hill in January. I made a mental note of the time to see how long it took to the summit in ideal summer conditions. It took 16 minutes. I think it could easily have taken three times that time back in the deep snows of last January. I know the summit seems so close, but I was right to start descending the hill. On this occasion, I felt strong and it was an easy walk to the summit.

IMGP9124_stitch.jpg


L to R Meall Doire Faid (Graham), Beinn Enaiglar (Corbett) and Beinn Dearg (Munro).

IMGP9156_stitch.jpg


I was surveying my descent route even before reaching the summit. The stalker's path that I was going to head for is clearly visible.

IMGP9187_stitch.jpg


Summit selfie done on a 12 second shutter delay. By the way, the BUFF Zinc Bimini Cap is excellent for hot weather.

IMGP9196.jpg


Another stitched panorama from the summit - How many Munros and Corbetts can you pick out? See the diagram below to check your answers.

IMGP9200_stitch.jpg


Screenshot 2021-08-07 18.51.jpg


Taken during the descent to the bealach between Meall Doire Faid and Beinn Enaiglar.

IMGP9216.jpg


I had been looking forward to the stalker's path as I had walked along it after a 4 day/3 night expedition finishing with Beinn Eglaidar. It was easy walking after a lot of pathless terrain over the previous few days and the weather had cleared. Again, it felt good to be back on a proper path.

Meall Doire Faid, An Teallach, Beinn Enaiglar.

IMGP9237_stitch.jpg


I left the stalker's path to take a more direct return to my car over Meall Leacachain. On the way, I saw a strange rock with antlers! The sounds of my camera caused the true owner to flee!

IMGP9260.jpg


IMGP9263.jpg


From Meall Leacachain towards Beinn Dearg.

IMGP9267.jpg


Looking east with Loch Droma right and Loch Glascarnoch left. Ben Wyvis and Little Wyvis are beyond Loch Glascarnoch.

IMGP9281.jpg


The full circuit given here makes a proper day of things and definitely added to the enjoyment, while still returning feeling reasonably fresh and strong. However, the orange juice and lemonade with ice at the Aultguish Inn did go down my neck rather quickly! I could never have completed this extended route in the conditions of last January.
Last edited by Yorjick on Wed Aug 11, 2021 2:01 pm, edited 2 times in total.
User avatar
Yorjick
Mountain Walker
 
Posts: 299
Munros:282   Corbetts:219
Fionas:75   Donalds:10
Sub 2000:22   Hewitts:158
Wainwrights:173   Islands:19
Joined: Sep 17, 2008
Location: Dornoch

Re: Meall Doire Faid Revisited

Postby Mountainlove » Tue Aug 10, 2021 10:18 pm

What a winter adventure! Great idea with the car mats in deep snow... Need to remember that one. Quite funny being beaten by a Graham, but in those conditions not surprisingly. Love the close up shots of the flowers
User avatar
Mountainlove
Munro compleatist
 
Posts: 1368
Munros:99   Corbetts:59
Fionas:7   Donalds:10
Sub 2000:3   
Islands:10
Joined: Feb 2, 2010
Location: North Ayrshire

Re: Meall Doire Faid Revisited

Postby Yorjick » Wed Aug 11, 2021 1:36 pm

Mountainlove wrote:What a winter adventure! Great idea with the car mats in deep snow... Need to remember that one. Quite funny being beaten by a Graham, but in those conditions not surprisingly. Love the close up shots of the flowers


You cannot really tell by appearances. Ben Wyvis had snow down to the road but the snow was not deep and others had compressed the snow. The summit ridge was also easy going. I seem to remember a van getting stuck on the car park that day.

Spring snow can be super fast on descent as it is relatively firm and evens out the ground.
User avatar
Yorjick
Mountain Walker
 
Posts: 299
Munros:282   Corbetts:219
Fionas:75   Donalds:10
Sub 2000:22   Hewitts:158
Wainwrights:173   Islands:19
Joined: Sep 17, 2008
Location: Dornoch

2 people think this report is great.
Register or Login
free to be able to rate and comment on reports (as well as access 1:25000 mapping).




Can you help support Walkhighlands?


Our forum is free from adverts - your generosity keeps it running.
Can you help support Walkhighlands and this community by donating by direct debit?



Return to Walk reports - Scotland

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Benrinneshiker, Haggisnachos, jmarkb, martin.h, Munromemories, noble_katie, scribe64, stuartie and 55 guests