walkhighlands

Share your personal walking route experiences in Scotland, and comment on other peoples' reports.
Warning Please note that hillwalking when there is snow lying requires an ice-axe, crampons and the knowledge, experience and skill to use them correctly. Summer routes may not be viable or appropriate in winter. See winter information on our skills and safety pages for more information.

Seasonal dysfunctionality - epic smorgasbord from Suardalan

Seasonal dysfunctionality - epic smorgasbord from Suardalan


Postby Graeme D » Sat Aug 10, 2024 10:27 pm

Munros included on this walk: Beinn Sgritheall

Corbetts included on this walk: Beinn na h-Eaglaise, Beinn nan Caorach

Fionas included on this walk: Beinn a' Chapuill

Date walked: 30/07/2024

Time taken: 12 hours

Distance: 24 km

Ascent: 2200m

10 people think this report is great.
Register or Login
free to be able to rate and comment on reports (as well as access 1:25000 mapping).

Today kicked off what was effectively Version 3 of my planned summer week gadding about the hills of Scotland in the seemingly never ending quest to reach the magical total of 282 Munros. Since 2008 when I registered on this site and effectively started what I guess could be called a hill "bagging" journey, my Munro quest has been slowed down by the fact that it has been running in tandem with similar quests to compleat other hill lists, most notably the Corbetts and the Fionas as they are known on here. Had all my trips since 2008 focused solely on Munros, I would have finished them some time ago. Despite sitting on 22 Donalds, I have managed to resist the temptation (principally from a gentleman by the name of Mr McConnachie) to try to add to this number for several years now, but have now had my head turned by some careless talk on a Whatsapp chat group about the Munro Tops. I also hold the owners of this site at least partly responsible for this since they introduced a Munro Top bagging log feature on here! :lol:

Sitting on 251 Munros and with 31 to go, I had sworn to myself that the priority for this week away would be the Munros. Version A of the plan was simple - leave Luna at home and head with the tent to Glenbrittle campsite on Skye to knock off a load of the 9 Cuillin Munros that are still red. That plan was kicked into touch by Mrs D who had a hissy fit at the idea of her week of absolute solitude at home without me and a hormonal 13 year old daughter being compromised by a farting dog :shock: . Version B included knocking off some of my furthest north red Munros, including three in Fisherfield and the far northern pair of Hope and Klibreck. I could still have implemented this plan but due to complications involving a pair of curtains and a transactional meeting with a random stranger in the carpark of the Co-op in Ballachulish (a long story, too long to go into even by the standards of my walk report intros! :lol: ), Version C came into being.

The culmination of all of these different versions of the plan involved turning up at the WH meet near Roybridge on the Friday evening. After heading with Ailsa to meet my mother in law in Dunblane (Ailsa was going to spend the week with her cousin at her gran's house in Hamilton), I made the long, sometimes tortuous journey up through Callander, Crianlarich, Tyndrum e.t.c. to the aforementioned Ballachulish meeting, then through Fort William (with a brief supply stop), Spean Bridge and Invergarry before heading through Glen Shiel and over the Mam Ratagan pass to park near the campsite at Moyle. Here I packed for a potential two nighter at Suardalan bothy and made the 50 minute or so walk in.

I had made this same walk in back in October after leaving the WH meet at Ratagan. Kev had joined me and after binning plans for Sgurr Mhic Barraich in atrocious weather, we had done the Sub2K Glas Bheinn near Glenelg. After soaking up more water than is contained in the North Atlantic, we had dried out as best as we could and headed for Suardalan. We almost didn't make it due to what would normally be little streams that needed to be crossed having turned into walls of raging white water. We eventually made it and enjoyed a warm, dry night watching bothy TV in the sanctuary of Suardalan. It was then, looking south west towards the clag shrouded red balloon of Beinn Sgritheall that I decided I would one day turn it blue from this side, rather than the usual 89° angled ascent route from Arnisdale on Loch Hourn.

Today was that day. I had spent a quiet night with Luna, a few beers and a modest bothy TV arrangement in the RH room while 5 young German scouts on a long distance walk from Glenfinnan to Kyle of Lochalsh played guitar and sang dib dib dib songs in the LH room. I was away from the bothy with a small daypack on at 07.14, heading south along the track between the delightful little knoll of Torr Beag and Loch Iain Mhic Aonghais.

IMG_4677.JPG
Leaving Suardalan - Sgurr Mhic Bharraich in the background

The initial few kilometres of the route was a delight, leading through the glen between A' Chrannag and Ruighe na Corpaich before arriving at the signposted junction by the lovely little mixed woodland plantation of Strath a'Chomair.

IMG_4689.JPG
Approaching Strath a'Chomair - Beinn Sgritheall and Beinn a'Chapiull looking good straight ahead

Of course today was not just about the Munro of Sgritheall (or even its NW Top). I also had my eyes on the satellite hills - primarily the Fiona of Beinn a'Chapuill to the north west and the Corbett of Beinn na h-Eaglaise to the south east. This would already constitute a big day but then of course there were Beinn nan Caorach and Beinn Clachach further south east still.

Given the unsettled weather of this summer and the evidence of this morning even at this relatively early hour, it was a good bet that I was going to experience the whole gamut in the course of whatever the route ended up being. The early morning sun was dappling the ground through the tree canopy but there was a distinct nip in the air and a real chill to the breeze which was coming and going at will. The skies above my head also hinted at a mixed day ahead. There were patches of blue scattered around but I had little confidence that the blue would ever outweigh the grey.

IMG_4693.JPG
Track alongside the Abhainn a'Ghlinne Bhig with Beinn a'Chapuill through the trees

Anyhow, as I turned off the track to cross the suspension bridge over the Abhainn a'Ghlinne Bhig, the prospect of having to put the waterproofs on was far from being my most pressing concern. I knew from researching previous reports that the state of the bridge would probably be questionable and indeed, it was barred and a sign warned against crossing. I say it was barred but it was a simple piece of netting that was easily lifted out of the way. I studied the bridge carefully, as well as the drop to the river below and after watching Luna gingerly step onto the structure, decided that the risk was acceptable. I did this on the basis of having absolutely no experience or qualifications in structural engineering but hey ho, it looked a better bet than trying to climb down and back up the other side.

IMG_4694.JPG
Fair warning!

Once safely across (it felt perfectly stable but like I said, my structural engineering background is somewhat limited), getting Luna across the deer fence was a much more serious undertaking. I searched for gaps and weaknesses in the fence to either side of the stile but in the end it was a case of manhandling her over said stile in a most ungraceful like operation.

The long graceful east ridge of Beinn a'Chapuill now lay ahead of me. It was one of the things that had stood out in the reports I had read as being a particularly fine feature of this hill and this route and I was keen to experience it. First of all though I had to negotiate a rather unappealing and rough broad section of tussocky grass underneath the power lines. It was warm, sweaty work, despite the hint of almost autumnal type weather in the air, and the dreaded midge were doing their best to keep close tabs on me. Once beyond the pylons and a brief flattening off of the gradient, the graceful east ridge began to take shape.

IMG_4698.JPG
Looking up the beautiful east ridge of Chapuill - bring this on!

The best views were back down the ridge as height was gained. Every time I stopped and turned to look back down, the ridge had taken on a slightly different character but still resembled a giant reptilian tail stretching out into the distance towards my starting point.

1.jpg
Back down the ridge - Sgurr Mhic Bharraich in the distance and little Tor Beag just left of centre

It was our 19th wedding anniversary and I had left a card and present for my wife hidden in the house with instructions to our daughter to message her mum and let her know where they were, an instruction I fully expected her to forget, at least until about 48 hours later! I would message too, but I knew that I may not have signal until I had reached a certain height. As it was, my wife beat me to it with a Happy Anniversary message to which I replied with the whereabouts of the card and present. She admitted to being relieved to discover that I had not, as she had thought, forgotten our anniversary for the first time in 19 years! 8)

IMG_4702.JPG
Gleann Beag below the east ridge

Despite the beauty of the east ridge, it was still a long, tough ascent. The views opened up as I gained height, across to the brooding bulk of Sgritheall with Eaglaise tucked in behind, and down Glean Beag and across Kylerhea to the pair of Grahams on Skye that, unbeknown to me yet, I would end up doing in two days time. But it was the views back down the ridge and across into the jumble of Kintail peaks that commanded most attention.

IMG_4703.JPG
Beinn na Eaglaise and Beinn Sgritheall

IMG_4709.JPG
Luna berating the straggler on the long ascent

IMG_4729.JPG
The Kylerhea Grahams on Skye

2.jpg
Down the ridge - what a majestic sight!

Eventually, the sinuous east ridge gave way to the gnarly summit plateau with its sprawling assortment of rocky knolls and little lochans. I made a bee line for the 742m point out to the north, partly because it was the named summit and partly because it would probably give the best views across Kylerhea.

IMG_4735.JPG
Gradient easing - looking south east across Beinn na h-Eaglaise towards the Barisdale hills

IMG_4736.JPG
Beinn Sgritheall's back door

IMG_4737.JPG
West to the named 742m summit

IMG_4739.JPG
Sgritheall across one of the summit plateau water bodies

IMG_4744.JPG
Glenelg and the Kylerhea hills from the 742m cairn

From there I looped back around to approach the 759m summit spot from the west, with a few stones lobbeed into the various lochain for Luna on the way. It was staying largely dry despite the heavy skies (the odd little short lived spit of rain aside) but it really didn't feel like we were on the cusp of August and what is supposed to be high summer. I know the Scottish summer is an unpredictable beast at best, but this summer has been particularly unreliable. It had much more the feeling of an early spring or late autumn hill walk. I was at least glad that the cloud was staying up high as being clagged in on this summit plateau would require some fairly serious navigational work.

IMG_4746.JPG
Beinn Sgritheall from the 755m point with the summit just ahead

From the summit I picked my way south east down easy enough slopes to the Bealach na h-Oidhche where I had a decision to make. Head straight up the steep northern face of the NW Top or sweep round on the curving ridge that ascends to the small flat area between there and the Munro summit at 974m. I opted for the latter.

IMG_4750.JPG
Curving Sgritheall ascent route

A short distance into the ascent, I stopped behind a large rock that offered at least some respite from the wind chill and had my lunch. Refuelled, I continued on up the curving ridge, relishing the prospect of summiting only my second Munro since September.

IMG_4754.JPG
Impressive cliffs and across Coire Min and Bealach Arnasdail to Sgurr na h-Eaglaise

IMG_4761.JPG
Looking down to the wee lochan in Coire Min - still a lot of distance and ascent left in this day yet!

IMG_4764.JPG
Back to the only tick of the day so far - Beinn a' Chapuill

3.jpg
Looking up my second very impressive ascent ridge of the day

When the ridge topped out, I headed across the plateau to the 928m Top before heading back SE and then SW to grab only my second Munro of 2024. Still, it was a significant one, leaving me a round 30 to go on the long journey.

IMG_4769.JPG
The 974m Munro summit of Sgritheall from the NW Top

IMG_4772.JPG
Looking back down my second very impressive ascent ridge of the day

IMG_4776.JPG
Bring on the final dirty thirty!

I fired a few messages off before leaving the summit and dropping south east down the grassy slopes to the broad saddle below the scree strewn slopes of the 906m south east summit. It was distinctly baltic for the last days of July but a gentle enough stroll on gradual slopes allowed for a casual hands in pockets daunder down to the bealach. Knoydart was full steam ahead and I looked forward to my upcoming visit to the Rough Bounds in a few weeks time with Kev to finally claim Ladhar Bheinn.

IMG_4779.JPG
Arnisdale, Corran, Loch Hourn and the shapely form of Druim Fada

At the 906m summit I met the only other human life forms I would encounter during the walk, two guys who had climbed some of the Dessary Munros the previous day and were taking a breather before their attempt on the summit! We chatted quite a bit about the vagaries of the Scottish summer weather, German scouts in bothies and the frustration of being caught behind long convoys of camper vans on roads with little or no passing opportunities. They said they had no intention of descending via their ascent route on the unfeasibly steep and loose scree path at which point I bade them farewell and set off down the unfeasibly steep and loose scree path before bearing left into the Bealach Arnasdail.

IMG_4783.JPG
The Devil's own scree slopes above Arnisdale

After much slip sliding and more than just a little industrial language, the solid, unmoving terrain of the bealach was reached and the next challenge stared me in the face - the no-frills, straight up and rather brutal looking northern slopes of Beinn na h-Eaglaise.

IMG_4788.JPG
Ladhar Bheinn across Loch Hourn from the Bealach Arnisdail

4.jpg
Home is where the bothy is - it's way down there beyond the loch

Despite their brutal appearance from the bealach below, the slopes of Bein na h-Eaglaise were not too bad. Steep, yes, but relatively straightforward and short lived. I soon reached the ridge a short distance from the summit and followed the line of old rusted fence posts up to claim the hat-trick - a Graham, a Munro and now a Corbett. When was the last time I did that in a day I wonder?

5.jpg
Approaching the summit of Eaglaise - to call it or not to call it!!??

6.jpg
Beinn nan Caorach from the summit of Eaglaise and Luna thinking "Dear God man, please tell me you're not seriously thinking what I think you're thinking!"

7.jpg
Dropping north east off Eaglaise - where now?

I had messaged a few folks saying I was at the summit of Eaglaise and that was me done for the day (long walk back to the bothy aside of course) but the high bealach linking my route home to Beinn nan Caorach was now making me have second thoughts. I fired off a few more messages and Kaiserstein helpfully replied with a breakdown of how much time and ascent my proposed detour would add to my day. Thanks Kaiser! What the hell - it's still not going to be a patch on the day on Beinn Dearg and neighbours from Braemore Junction, so just do it man!

I made quick progress down to the broad, high bealach before swinging right and up the north ridge of Caorach. Call me pessimistic if you will, but something told me that adding Caorach to the mix would not come quite as easily and cheaply as it appeared it would. Still, in for a penny!

8.jpg
Looking back to the beautiful profile of Eaglaise from the north east

I had committed to adding Beinn na Caorach to the route despite my earlier conviction that the Graham-Munro-Corbett hat trick would suffice and as I made my way across the broad, flat bealach and up the north ridge of my second Ronnie of the day, the Weather Gods clearly decided that my impudence could not go unpunished. The rain came on and for the first time in a long day of unseasonal weather, the waterproof trousers went on. My impudence was rewarded with sketchy summit views when I got there!

IMG_4801.JPG
Sumptuous summit views south across Loch Hourn

I didn't dally at the summit. It was still a big walk ahead to drop north down over Sgurr Dearg to rejoin the track that would eventually lead me back to Suardalan. At least the Weather Gods seemed to relent and show a bit of clemency now that common sense had prevailed and I was calling it a day!

IMG_4804.JPG
Lead on Luna!

IMG_4805.JPG
Back to Eaglaise and Sgritheall

IMG_4810.JPG
Beinn nan Caorach from Sgurr Dearg

It was a long but enjoyable walk back out once down onto the track in Ghleann Aoidhdailean and the Weather Gods actually treated me with a little bit of sunshine in the closing stages.

IMG_4813.JPG
Better late than never with the sunshine!

The sunshine was short lived but at least the waterproofs were off now and remained off for the rest of the walk. It had maybe felt quite autumnal for a walk in the dying days of July but at least it had stayed largely dry. I looked at my watch and wondered if it would be just under or just over 12 hours for the route. It was going to be close either way!

IMG_4814.JPG
A last look back to Sgritheall and Chapuill

I got back to Suardalan at 19.12 - two minutes short of a round the clock job. There was no sign of the German scouts or anyone else for that matter although a young Czech couple would arrive later just as I was getting ready to hit the hay.

I reflected on a great hill day - easily my biggest day of the year and one the seeds of which were sown back on a wet, stormy October night in Suardalan bothy 10 months previously. I do love it when a plan comes together! Now for the rest of the week!
User avatar
Graeme D
 
Posts: 4065
Munros:253   Corbetts:130
Fionas:81   Donalds:22
Sub 2000:62   Hewitts:36
Wainwrights:28   Islands:6
Joined: Oct 17, 2008
Location: Perth

Re: Seasonal dysfunctionality - epic smorgasbord from Suarda

Postby zatapathique » Tue Aug 13, 2024 7:52 pm

That plan was kicked into touch by Mrs D who had a hissy fit at the idea of her week of absolute solitude at home without me and a hormonal 13 year old daughter being compromised by a farting dog :shock: . Version B included knocking off some of my furthest north red Munros, including three in Fisherfield and the far northern pair of Hope and Klibreck. I could still have implemented this plan but due to complications involving a pair of curtains and a transactional meeting with a random stranger in the carpark of the Co-op in Ballachulish (a long story, too long to go into even by the standards of my walk report intros! :lol: ), Version C came into being.


:lol: Wonderful! I really like your introductions, this one especially. There's a nice German expression called "Kopfkino" ("head cinema"), which means that if you read or hear something, your head starts playing the scene as you imagine it, just like in a movie. The bit about Luna farting and shocking your daughter definitely set my mind reels in motion.

Kudos for a great round and the photos, these ridges look superb! :clap: I thought that the hills East of Sgritheall looked beautiful when I was up there a couple of months before. Well done Luna as well to indulge her master's whims.

It is really hard to stay focused on the Munros with all these other beautiful (often even more beautiful) hills around. But, alas, climbing the Munros from the continent makes me focus on them first, but then! :wink:

Only 30 more to go sounds great, I'm glad it's less than 200 to go, the next milestone will be 150 to go. :lol:
User avatar
zatapathique
Mountain Walker
 
Posts: 137
Munros:107   Corbetts:4
Sub 2000:1   Hewitts:19
Wainwrights:26   
Joined: Sep 3, 2014
Location: France

Re: Seasonal dysfunctionality - epic smorgasbord from Suarda

Postby Verylatestarter » Thu Aug 15, 2024 2:37 pm

That's a great round, respect to you and Luna for completing it. I had intended to do a similar route from Balvaid in Summer but ended up doing Sgritheall only via the bridge and up the Allt Stath a Chomair. For those reluctant to attempt the dubious looking bridge the fords on the opposite (i.e. South side) of Strath a Chomair are fairly easy in dry weather. The only concern I had regarding the full round was the steep descent from the 906 top and the steep ascent of Beinn na h-Eaglaise in wet conditions.

Thanks for posting.

John
Verylatestarter
Mountain Walker
 
Posts: 225
Munros:41   Corbetts:18
Fionas:3   
Sub 2000:1   
Islands:5
Joined: Oct 14, 2020
Location: East Anglia (South Norfolk)

Re: Seasonal dysfunctionality - epic smorgasbord from Suarda

Postby Graeme D » Thu Aug 15, 2024 10:21 pm

zatapathique wrote:
That plan was kicked into touch by Mrs D who had a hissy fit at the idea of her week of absolute solitude at home without me and a hormonal 13 year old daughter being compromised by a farting dog :shock: . Version B included knocking off some of my furthest north red Munros, including three in Fisherfield and the far northern pair of Hope and Klibreck. I could still have implemented this plan but due to complications involving a pair of curtains and a transactional meeting with a random stranger in the carpark of the Co-op in Ballachulish (a long story, too long to go into even by the standards of my walk report intros! :lol: ), Version C came into being.


:lol: Wonderful! I really like your introductions, this one especially. There's a nice German expression called "Kopfkino" ("head cinema"), which means that if you read or hear something, your head starts playing the scene as you imagine it, just like in a movie. The bit about Luna farting and shocking your daughter definitely set my mind reels in motion.

Kudos for a great round and the photos, these ridges look superb! :clap: I thought that the hills East of Sgritheall looked beautiful when I was up there a couple of months before. Well done Luna as well to indulge her master's whims.

It is really hard to stay focused on the Munros with all these other beautiful (often even more beautiful) hills around. But, alas, climbing the Munros from the continent makes me focus on them first, but then! :wink:

Only 30 more to go sounds great, I'm glad it's less than 200 to go, the next milestone will be 150 to go. :lol:


Kopfkino! 8) 8) As a languages teacher (including German, but sadly VERY limited opportunities to teach that in my or any other Scottish school these days), that sort of knowledge is right up my street. I think I have taught German during one school year in the last decade or so, and really don't see myself having the opportunity to do so again in the remainder of my teaching career, especially if my move towards delivering our Outdoor Education programme becomes more permanent and established. I wasn't aware of this phrase before. Never having lived in Germany (unlike France), I don't have the same level of more colloquial language that I do with French. I will mention the phrase to my colleague who tends to teach what little German we have these days and whose grasp of that particular language is far superior to mine. 8)
User avatar
Graeme D
 
Posts: 4065
Munros:253   Corbetts:130
Fionas:81   Donalds:22
Sub 2000:62   Hewitts:36
Wainwrights:28   Islands:6
Joined: Oct 17, 2008
Location: Perth

Re: Seasonal dysfunctionality - epic smorgasbord from Suarda

Postby Graeme D » Thu Aug 15, 2024 10:26 pm

Verylatestarter wrote:That's a great round, respect to you and Luna for completing it. I had intended to do a similar route from Balvaid in Summer but ended up doing Sgritheall only via the bridge and up the Allt Stath a Chomair. For those reluctant to attempt the dubious looking bridge the fords on the opposite (i.e. South side) of Strath a Chomair are fairly easy in dry weather. The only concern I had regarding the full round was the steep descent from the 906 top and the steep ascent of Beinn na h-Eaglaise in wet conditions.

Thanks for posting.

John


Thank you John. It is a cracking round. The descent from the 906m top down to the bealach is pretty gruesome. There's no other way to put that. The ascent from there up to Eaglaise is brutally steep but fortunately pretty short lived. At least it felt that way to me, but maybe I was in a kind of daze by then and had lost all grasp of time! :lol: In very wet conditions, yes, I can imagine it could be quite greasy!
User avatar
Graeme D
 
Posts: 4065
Munros:253   Corbetts:130
Fionas:81   Donalds:22
Sub 2000:62   Hewitts:36
Wainwrights:28   Islands:6
Joined: Oct 17, 2008
Location: Perth

Re: Seasonal dysfunctionality - epic smorgasbord from Suarda

Postby malky_c » Fri Aug 16, 2024 9:40 am

Good route - Sgritheall is definitely much nicer from the north even if the best views are on the Arnisdale side! Still, most of these hills are either straight up or straight down with no messing about. Nice move adding an extra hill on the end. I was interested what you might have to say about the route up Beinn na h-Eaglaise from Sgritheall but it doesn't sound like you found it too bad. That was one of our possible descent routes when we were up there recently but I had a memory of it being less than fun (my brief note from going down in 2009 says 'NW ridge very steep, particularly lower down. Needed some greasy grass scrambling, but got down in the end'). Maybe it would have been OK after all!
User avatar
malky_c
 
Posts: 6404
Munros:282   Corbetts:222
Fionas:219   Donalds:80+37
Sub 2000:331   Hewitts:281
Wainwrights:140   Islands:43
Joined: Nov 22, 2009
Location: Inverness/Glasgow

Re: Seasonal dysfunctionality - epic smorgasbord from Suarda

Postby Graeme D » Fri Aug 16, 2024 4:47 pm

malky_c wrote:Good route - Sgritheall is definitely much nicer from the north even if the best views are on the Arnisdale side! Still, most of these hills are either straight up or straight down with no messing about. Nice move adding an extra hill on the end. I was interested what you might have to say about the route up Beinn na h-Eaglaise from Sgritheall but it doesn't sound like you found it too bad. That was one of our possible descent routes when we were up there recently but I had a memory of it being less than fun (my brief note from going down in 2009 says 'NW ridge very steep, particularly lower down. Needed some greasy grass scrambling, but got down in the end'). Maybe it would have been OK after all!


The route up Eaglaise from the bealach looked horrific and was extremely steep but wasn't nearly as bad in reality as it looked for some reason!
User avatar
Graeme D
 
Posts: 4065
Munros:253   Corbetts:130
Fionas:81   Donalds:22
Sub 2000:62   Hewitts:36
Wainwrights:28   Islands:6
Joined: Oct 17, 2008
Location: Perth

Re: Seasonal dysfunctionality - epic smorgasbord from Suarda

Postby kevsbald » Fri Aug 16, 2024 9:36 pm

:clap: A lot to be said for hatching plans in bothies. The view down that Fiona is sublime. Another Munro tick too! Math fhein, balach!
User avatar
kevsbald
Stravaiging
 
Posts: 2306
Munros:282   Corbetts:134
Fionas:82   Donalds:55
Sub 2000:17   Hewitts:17
Wainwrights:29   
Joined: Jan 15, 2009
Location: Bearsden

10 people think this report is great.
Register or Login
free to be able to rate and comment on reports (as well as access 1:25000 mapping).




Can you help support Walkhighlands?


Our forum is free from adverts - your generosity keeps it running.
Can you help support Walkhighlands and this community by donating by direct debit?



Return to Walk reports - Scotland

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 29 guests