walkhighlands

Share your personal walking route experiences in Scotland, and comment on other peoples' reports.
Warning Please note that hillwalking when there is snow lying requires an ice-axe, crampons and the knowledge, experience and skill to use them correctly. Summer routes may not be viable or appropriate in winter. See winter information on our skills and safety pages for more information.

A most successful failure

A most successful failure


Postby jpoldy » Sun Nov 24, 2024 8:32 pm

Route description: Ben Challum, near Tyndrum

Munros included on this walk: An Gearanach, Ben Challum

Date walked: 17/11/2024

Time taken: 7.8 hours

Distance: 30.5 km

Ascent: 1913m

29 people think this report is great.
Register or Login
free to be able to rate and comment on reports (as well as access 1:25000 mapping).

In my peripheral vision, the first inkling that the conception of this adventure may have been slightly underbaked, looms from the darkness as the A82 meanders through Glen Coe. I steal a glance away from the headlights of oncoming traffic. Those are definitely snow-encrusted slopes gleaming in the blackness… This does not, to be fair, come as a surprise. The forecast has measured up to its predictions for snow showers today, with a fine day in the hills to follow. I tell myself that a little snow under foot will be no bother, and anyway, perhaps the conditions are localised, and further on it’ll be different? Who can say where this stroke of delusion comes from; it definitely will not be milder on Scotland’s rooftop further on.

Rolling into Fort William around 8:30pm, the surrounds are hard to assess in the dark. We pootle on down Glen Nevis to the Lower Falls carpark. The carpark, unsurprisingly, is empty. A sign states that overnight camping in tents or vehicles is prohibited, but I fail to notice this, so we do just that. The Great Scottish Dingo* and I curl up in my little hatchback and sleep snuggly and deeply. At least one of us snores.

We wake around 5:45 (perhaps I don’t sleep that soundly). The aim is to do the Ring of Steall circuit… possibly doubling back over the Devil’s Ridge and adding in the two western Mamores, but this will be assessed as the day unwinds. The idea is to get a head start on the day by covering the stretch along the glen in the early darkness, rather than starting the walk from the carpark at the far end of the Glen Nevis road. Of course, one could advocate for leaving the easy miles for the end of the walk, when weariness won’t impact technical thinking, and navigational focus isn’t (as much) required. But I never fancy a return-to-car schlep after the epitome of a hike is behind me. This is my usual strategy: if there’s going to be a slog at one end of the day, I prefer to get it done early. (It should be said that the track from Lower Falls to the Ben Nevis falls is pleasant, and hardly a slog. I suspect though, given the shortening mid-November days and the possibility of an extended route, this stretch will be done in darkness at one or another end of the day, so will stick to the road).


An Gearanach from Lower Falls.gpx Open full screen  NB: Walkhighlands is not responsible for the accuracy of gpx files in users posts


With so few visitors at this time of year, there is plenty of free parking to be found off the Glen Nevis road. But I am unaware of this so dutifully pays the £12 for 12 hours to leave the car at Lower Falls, wondering if this is really necessary in November. Still, if these pounds will contribute to maintaining this stunning area, I am more than happy to. Anyhow, surely that will atone for the clandestine car-camping, and it’s hardly exorbitant for a day’s entertainment. It’s 6:20 before we are on our way (why does it take so long to get a wriggle-on? It’s not as though there was any real packing to do).

The first miles along the road are easy and quick. I don a headtorch to negotiate the rocky track through the woodland, but the moon is bright, and I don’t need the extra light once the track spills out again into the open glen.
Glen Nevis by moonlight.jpg

I ignore the turn-off to the steal cable bridge – this would be fun to try, but the wonder-dog assures me that he is less keen, and with his absence of opposable thumbs, the prospects of his balancing are poor. Instead, we cross a few hundred meters further upstream, where the water is shallow after the river eases back to the east. I reflect that if I were a pole-using hiker, this would be an apt time to put them to use. I am not. But the water is low, the rocks only mildly slippery, and we cross without difficulty. It’s a boggy 200m jaunt across the grassland to join the stalkers’ path east of Steall Falls, as it turns south east and starts to climb.

The route is steep, but easy-going on a good track that skirts a landslide and climbs the left side of the Allt Coire Chadha Chaoruinn gully (however that is pronounced). The sky takes on a faint pallor as we cross over to the right side at around 390m, and the track throws short switch backs, leading away from the gully. Another ~150m elevation gain, and the first dustings of snow furnish the hillside. The ascent eases momentarily, until the crest of the spur is reached. The track turns south east again, and continues to climb. Although steep, none of the climbing is particularly onerous; the path is excellent, and we take ample breathers to gawk in awe at the valley we have climbed from, and the bulk of Ben Nevis and friends across the far side.
20241117_075532.jpg
reaching the spur of An Gearanach, around 630m

Climbing the spur to the summit of An Gearanach, gawking becomes the main pursuit of the morning. The sun, emerging as a glowing orb on the horizon over Binnein Mor is spilling a golden fire in front of it and a clean, pastel light across the Ring of Steall. I stop so frequently to try to capture the moment that the cold quickly bites into my hands, and it is time to contemplate my clothing choices. Mitts and jacket are added. The Great Scottish Dingo, meanwhile, is contemplating the snowscape, entirely in his element.
20241117_081302.jpg
sunrise

20241117_081913.jpg
more sunrise

20241117_081952_2.jpg
looking across to Sgùrr a'Mhàim

20241117_081959.jpg
back across to Ben Nevis and Càrn Mòr Dearg

20241117_082308.jpg
Gus, the Scottish dingo, admiring the sunrise

20241117_082854.jpg
what are you waiting for?

Munro tops are always fun – their variety makes each one special – but this first of the day is amongst my favourites. The light, the snow, the complete solitude. So early, the only tracks in the snow are mine and those of the wonder-dog. There is nothing quite so special as feeling like you’re the only one in the world, in the most beautiful place in the world (even on a busy summer day, this place is so spectacular that it is no doubt still a phenomenon). I spend a few minutes at the summit, struggling to determine which direction presents the most spectacular view, before giving up and awarding them equal points for awe and splendour, and pressing on.
20241117_082122.jpg
'little' Binnein Beag with Binnein Mor

20241117_082922.jpg
looking back to the Ben Nevis range, as we approach the summit of An Gearanach

20241117_082907.jpg

20241117_083100.jpg
what lies ahead, looking on to Stob Chore a'Chairn with Am Bodach in the background

And then, not far beyond An Gearanach’s summit, the ridge becomes very… ridgey. I have a good head for heights, but it doesn’t take long to abruptly reconsider the day. I am alone, there is snow – which is good quality but obscures route choices – and there is wonder-dog to consider, as the best route over the rocky ridge for a biped and a quadruped may be different. This section of the ridge is described as a little harder than the Càrn Mòr Dearg Arete, which we had no issues navigating in fine conditions some years previously. But today the prospects seem unwise. We may well be able to pick our way past this section, but if I have a sense of hesitation here already – a section without anticipated difficulty – the Devil’s ridge is not looking promising. And should we have to turn back at that point, it’ll be a long return, with this same section to renegotiate. I have no desire to turn a magical day into one with anxiety about whether I am making a wise call.

So, with little debate, the Great Scottish Dingo and I follow our tracks back through the snow.**

The descent, of course, is steep, but without difficulty. Wonder dog expresses his jubilance with a snow-frolic (anyone who has seen a dog doing zoomies in the snow will appreciate the pure joy that observing this brings).
20241117_094018_2.jpg
returning to the Glen

Back on the valley floor, the day is starting to unfold, with scattered hikers peppered along the trail. Passing, again, the steal-cable bridge, here now is an opportunity to test it out – why not? – just for fun. I am average height and am surprised how far the hand rails feel to reach (can children use this thing?!). I intend only to take a few steps out along the cable to see what it’s like, but realise – oops – that once started, there’s no real way to turn around! So, it’s over to the far side, about-face, and back again. Wonder-dog is watching quizzically from the far shore, and is very grateful that there was an easy alternative to wade across the shallows upstream.
20241117_095333.jpg
Steall Falls in daylight

20241117_095852.jpg

20241117_095904.jpg
a long reach

We are back at the Lower Falls carpark by 10:50, Ring of Steall attempt aborted - not to mention the Western friends. This doesn’t feel like defeat. It had not been a difficult decision to turn back. The morning was glorious. The hike up has been one of my all-time favourites – for which there is stiff competition – and I will enjoy doing it again on another occasion. Although we topped only one Munro of a 4-Munro circuit, the return distance covered is approximately the same as the intended route, and the Great Scottish Dingo is suitably tired, always an indicator of a successful Munro day. There is plenty of time to refuel with a hot chocolate and cake at the delightful Wildcat Café in Fort William, before the long drive home.

A second wind

Ben Challam.gpx Open full screen  NB: Walkhighlands is not responsible for the accuracy of gpx files in users posts


Ben Challam is en route as we drive south, and I make a spur-of-the-moment decision to romp up its boggy path, setting off around 13:20. I am clearly still swooning from the morning’s achievements, as we pass several descending parties looking less enamoured by the mud, snow and brewing cloud.
20241117_140153.jpg
the muddy ascent of Ben Challam

20241117_145324.jpg
looking back as cloud skims over the ascent path

At the summit, the wind is picking up, it is starting to snow, and the short daylight is hurtling towards evening. We plunge through the snow, down the north-western shoulder with the hope that this will make for a less boggy return circuit, but find it similarly marshy. Picking up the farm track on the lower east flank of Beinn Chaorach, we follow it down the Gleann a’Chlachain, to join a short few hundred meters of the West Highland Way from the Wigwams near Auchtertyre back to Kirkton farm. Finally, we are back at the car around 16:40, both now thoroughly cactused, ready for a meal, a bath, and bed.***

This will be my last hiking for the season. I couldn’t have wished for a better day.


* Gus is neither Scottish, nor a Dingo. But he is a dog, and definitely wonderful.
** This was the first time I have ever turned back on a hike on account of losing my nerve. The conditions on the day were perfect. I have no doubt that other walkers would comfortably have managed the snow and terrain, without issue. I’ve read many brilliant trip reports from people who have completed this, or more challenging routes in far more strenuous conditions, and I’m sure the authors of these hiked well within their comfort levels and abilities – or acknowledged if this were not the case! I don’t believe I was poorly equipped, or ever in any danger. But I was out there to have fun. I didn’t want to be outside my comfort zone (although this, too, is fun sometimes!). For me, this was the perfect out-and-back trip.
***cactused: Australian slang for tired/broken/depleted/wiped out. I always use this term with affection to mean a wearying and satisfying day in the hills 😊
Last edited by jpoldy on Mon Nov 25, 2024 8:27 pm, edited 1 time in total.
jpoldy
 
Posts: 5
Munros:102   Corbetts:1
Donalds:1
Joined: Nov 19, 2016

Re: A most successful failure

Postby johnbythell » Mon Nov 25, 2024 12:28 pm

Fabulous, great pics and a thoroughly enjoyable read - thanks for the report! There have to come times when you have to make a decision to turn around and you clearly made the right (well argued) decision here - great 'mountain sense'. :clap: :clap: PS - I reckon that wire bridge is by far the most terrifying part of the Ring of Steal (on a good day without snow and ice) - it is insane!
User avatar
johnbythell
Mountain Walker
 
Posts: 200
Munros:181   
Joined: Sep 4, 2017

Re: A most successful failure

Postby jpoldy » Mon Nov 25, 2024 8:29 pm

johnbythell wrote:Fabulous, great pics and a thoroughly enjoyable read - thanks for the report! There have to come times when you have to make a decision to turn around and you clearly made the right (well argued) decision here - great 'mountain sense'. :clap: :clap: PS - I reckon that wire bridge is by far the most terrifying part of the Ring of Steal (on a good day without snow and ice) - it is insane!


Thanks! I enjoyed writing it! My first trip report, and I got to relive the whole magical day 😊
jpoldy
 
Posts: 5
Munros:102   Corbetts:1
Donalds:1
Joined: Nov 19, 2016

Re: A most successful failure

Postby Graeme D » Mon Nov 25, 2024 11:09 pm

Excellent pictures and great story telling! I think I will enjoy reading about the further exploits of yourself and the Wonder Dog who is neither Scottish nor dingo! :lol: :clap:
User avatar
Graeme D
 
Posts: 4105
Munros:259   Corbetts:130
Fionas:83   Donalds:25
Sub 2000:62   Hewitts:36
Wainwrights:28   Islands:6
Joined: Oct 17, 2008
Location: Perth

Re: A most successful failure

Postby jpoldy » Tue Nov 26, 2024 6:40 pm

Graeme D wrote:Excellent pictures and great story telling! I think I will enjoy reading about the further exploits of yourself and the Wonder Dog who is neither Scottish nor dingo! :lol: :clap:

Thanks Graeme D! There's a lot of Scotland still to explore, so you'll be sure to hear more of the Adventures of Wonder Dog and me 😁
jpoldy
 
Posts: 5
Munros:102   Corbetts:1
Donalds:1
Joined: Nov 19, 2016

Re: A most successful failure

Postby dogplodder » Tue Nov 26, 2024 8:14 pm

Indeed it was, as your photos demonstrate, and a suitably auspicious debut for Gus, the wonder dog of uncertain nationality and breed! :clap:
User avatar
dogplodder
 
Posts: 4420
Munros:243   Corbetts:78
Fionas:32   
Sub 2000:33   Hewitts:4
Wainwrights:9   Islands:24
Joined: Jul 16, 2011

Re: A most successful failure

Postby jpoldy » Thu Nov 28, 2024 11:00 am

We've been out traipsing Scotland's hills for a few years, so the debut is only in the reporting. 'Bagging' munros is an excellent excuse to explore new territory, but I would happily return to most.
jpoldy
 
Posts: 5
Munros:102   Corbetts:1
Donalds:1
Joined: Nov 19, 2016

Re: A most successful failure

Postby Mr Bump » Wed Dec 04, 2024 10:32 am

Congratulations on winning the walk report prize! Very well deserved for an entertaining report full of fun and sensible decisions. Something we should all aspire to. Plus one for sharing the fun with a dog - they add so much!
User avatar
Mr Bump
Mountain Walker
 
Posts: 21
Munros:2   Corbetts:1
Sub 2000:5   
Joined: Jun 29, 2024
Location: Stanley, Perth, UK (soon to be Methven, also near Perth)

Re: A most successful failure

Postby dominic6hornton » Fri Dec 06, 2024 10:11 am

Great write up - and I have to say exactly the same happened to me when I attempted it about one year ago in icy conditions !(although without a canine pal!) - I tried it in the same direction (completed An Gearanach first) and then turned back at precisely the same spot .!! The rocks at this short stretch of scramble were frozen/icy , and I did not have the nerve to cross this , say only 10 - 20 m , section . It was a beautiful sunny crisp day, so I just stopped, gathered my thoughts, enjoyed the amazing views for about 15 mins in the lovely sunshine , and then turned back, lol. BTW, I don't think the Devils Ridge section is as spicy as this section (having now done both). Interestingly I did complete this stretch (and the whole of Ring of Steall) only a month ago , i was delighted - but there was no ice or snow, still quite mild. But it was wet and quite slippy, and not that straight forward so I think you (and I ) made the right decision at the time. I loved your description of the Steel rope bridge - it surprised me aswell, you have to concentrate, lol.
Well done for getting the WalkHighlands prize - great photos and description

Dominic
dominic6hornton
Mountain Walker
 
Posts: 4
Joined: Jul 30, 2023

Re: A most successful failure

Postby Girlsinthehills » Tue Dec 17, 2024 10:43 am

Thoroughly enjoyed this report and the photographs. I've turned back on hiking trips on several occasions, mainly due to a combination of strengthening winds and heavy rain. The hills will always be there for another day.
Maybe one day I will meet the great Scottish Dingo in the hills, he sounds a fantastic dog
Girlsinthehills
Mountain Walker
 
Posts: 2
Joined: Aug 8, 2021

Re: A most successful failure

Postby tomyboy73 » Thu Dec 19, 2024 6:55 am

That's a great first report. We attempted this in similar conditions many moons ago and turned back a little bit further along. No failure when you return alive :lol:
Did return to do the full Ring one summer
User avatar
tomyboy73
Mountain Walker
 
Posts: 1099
Munros:194   Corbetts:47
Fionas:12   Donalds:3
Sub 2000:9   Hewitts:6
Wainwrights:3   Islands:5
Joined: Jan 21, 2010
Walk wish-list

29 people think this report is great.
Register or Login
free to be able to rate and comment on reports (as well as access 1:25000 mapping).




Can you help support Walkhighlands?


Our forum is free from adverts - your generosity keeps it running.
Can you help support Walkhighlands and this community by donating by direct debit?



Return to Walk reports - Scotland

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: EmeraldQuiche, lynnscottm, Mrs Scoob, stevenmcintosh and 29 guests