Travel and Coronavirus
Temporary Coronavirus restrictions and travel advice applies until Monday 26th October.
Click for details
by Morag M » Sun Jul 04, 2010 5:13 pm
Munros included on this walk: Beinn Ime, Beinn Narnain
Date walked: 02/07/2010
Time taken: 10 hoursRegister or Login free to be able to rate and comment on reports (as well as access 1:25000 mapping).
We walked along the road past the power station then soon turned left onto the tarmac road which lead under the railway, we kept on this road, passed the electric substation, somewhere along this road we turned left and passed a dam, just after the dam was a gate with a wooden stile which we climbed over and passed a brick shelter on the right hand side, we carried on this path until it came to an end, there was a memorial plaque at the end of this road, not knowing where to go now we crossed the stream and headed into the trees, no path obvious to us, we started to climb a mountain which we believed was Beinn Narnain, this was slightly hairy (at times on all fours), however the views were terrific, (my camera does not do them justice - will have to get a new one) when we reached the top we were sure we were on Narnain (however asked a couple who were at the top just to confirm) it was extremely windy on the plateau, we explored the summit for a while - found this great fun, we then headed off down Narnain in the direction of Beinn Ime, going up and down was not hard, and we soon arrived at the top of Ime, we headed to the right first to the small pile of stones, then we took the left up the path to the highest summit, at this time the mist came down and it was raining, we sheltered a bit in this summit, views were magnificent when the mist cleared, then as we were still feeling fairly fit we decided to head for Ben Vane, we left Ime and headed down the grassy slopes of I don't know where, there was no obvious path, very hard going, the rain came down heavier and we decided to leave Ben Vane for another day - (really my hubby's idea, although I don't think we would have found it anyway It was hard going making our way down to the bottom, we had to keep going up and down as there were a lot of steep drops, eventually we got near the bottom and could see a stream, we tried to walk along side of this (we knew we were heading in the right sort of direction) it was too marshy (no path), we eventually came to pine trees and headed toward them, we clambered along a metal type fence at the side of them, to avoid getting out feet stuck in the boggy grounds, after a while we headed off to the right then came to the dam that we had passed on the way up, however we were on the wrong side and had to clamber down rocks (at this point I did not think I was going to make it) we literally had to slide down these rocks on our backs, eventually our feet hit the road on which we had came up from I did not know whether to laugh or cry at this point (my hubby was singing Valdaree, Valdaraa), we arrived back at our car at 10pm soaking wet and glad to be alive. . If anyone can help tell me where I went wrong and where I was walking I would grateful.
by kinley » Sun Jul 04, 2010 6:07 pm
Sounds as though a fair bit of work is needed on the navigation side of things. 8O
by Paul Webster » Sun Jul 04, 2010 6:20 pm
If anyone can help tell me where I went wrong and where I was walking I would grateful.
Not sure anyone is going to be able to work that out.
There is lots of info on map reading in the skills and safety section - might be worth practicing some of the skills on better days where you can see where you are going, or considering a course.
To post photos, there is an 'add photograph or map' tab below the window where you type in your post.
by skuk007 » Sun Jul 04, 2010 6:48 pm
sarahkirsty wrote: not knowing where to go now we crossed the stream and headed into the trees, no path obvious to us, we started to climb a mountain which we believed was Beinn Narnain,
Agree with Kinley about the navigation thing, I would say the above is where it probably started going wrong.
by tomyboy73 » Sun Jul 04, 2010 6:58 pm
by RadMan » Sun Jul 04, 2010 7:41 pm
You would have been better coming from the Arrochar side and just doing the two. 3 was maybe a bit too much as you are just starting out.
If i was starting from where you did then i would have done Ben Vane and called it a day at that.
by iainwatson » Mon Jul 05, 2010 11:27 am
by davidmhodgey » Mon Jul 05, 2010 1:56 pm
Probably best to study the map in relation to where you're parking before you leave, that way you'll have a vague idea of the topography and can check as your suspected position against landmarks (there are lots of them around there).
So to sum up, if it's a bad forecast or a dubious one, I stick to things with good handrail features, like following an escarpment or line of cliffs to a summit and back - something you can obviously see in a mist...
Hope that helps some...
- mountain coward
by iainwatson » Mon Jul 05, 2010 2:45 pm
sorry but just really disagree with that point,it sounds as if she took a pretty treacherous route to get to Narnain and could easily have fallen(through exhaustion or confusion) and really hurt herself,to be on all fours climbing a mountain is hard enough without the fact she didnt know where she actually was and had no way of being able to find out.
think about it,if she had injured herself,where would she have told the rescue teams to get her? somewhere in the arrochar hills?
i am certainly not trying to put her off and would encourage her to keep going but with the proper research and skills to do so.
by Paul Webster » Mon Jul 05, 2010 2:47 pm
I think where you went wrong was with the route choice. Really best to stick to the main established routes on decent days to gain experience and try to improve / learn map-reading from there.
davidmhodgey wrote:Ach most people do stupid things when they start out. Sounds like you had a nice wee adventure! I don't see how you could get hurt around there. I mean, if it's too steep, head back. If you're in water up to your neck, head back, if cows start staring at you, head back.
Like the cows bit... but cows are normally fine. You just have to remember a few rules... make sure they are cows and don't have that little tuft under their bellies remember that, apart from being in a bunch, which makes them feel brave, they are basically still scared of you so if you turn and square up to them if they charge you and make a loud noise and make threatening movements with your arms, they will invariably back off... The only exception to this (even with a cow in a bad mood) is if they have calves or you have a dog... in that case keep well clear!
But be assured, cows think it's great fun to all charge at you across a field in a wild bunch - they will only mow you down if they can't stop in time though!
- mountain coward