Stay at home
Scotland is under national lockdown. People are asked to stay at home except for essential purposes.
Click for details
Tower and Ptarmigan: a tale of two ridges
by Riverman » Fri Mar 25, 2016 4:52 pm
Munros included on this walk: Ben Nevis, Meall nan Tarmachan
Date walked: 20/03/2016
Time taken: 12.42 hours
Distance: 25.2 km
Ascent: 2055m1 person thinks this report is great. Register or Login free to be able to rate and comment on reports (as well as access 1:25000 mapping).
Last weekend, the ghosts of January 2014 March 2015 were well and truly banished. On Saturday I stormed over the Ptarmigan Ridge in glorious spring sunshine. On Sunday, I reached the highest point in Britain for the first time in my life across snow, rock and ice on Tower Ridge. What a different feeling from a year ago! This is my tale of two ridges.
Day 1 // Saturday 19 March 2016 // Ptarmigan Ridge, Meall nan Tarmachan // 13.9km // 5hr // 904m ascent
Late on Friday evening, driving from Glasgow airport to Crianlarich there were still doubts in the back of my mind about whether this would be a successful weekend or not. Since last summer I’ve been walking well and seem to have put injury behind me. Only recently I have climbed Cyfrwy Arete on Cadair Idris - a really big day out. Yet despite these recent successes, and being a worrier by nature, the fear of an IT band flare up always lingers but I needn’t have worried.
On Saturday I hit the trail early from the Lawers car park. Climbing through a cloud inversion it was not long before I was basking in glorious sunshine and well on my way to the first top at 923m. Much of the snow had gone but on the final slope to Meall nan Tarmachan there was still a considerable amount. Soft enough to keep my crampons in my bag, I nevertheless had axe in hand on the final steep ascent where I met some lads from Stirling enjoying the summit. Not even noon and one had already cracked open a beer! The views were stupendous. Ben Nevis, my target for the next day was clearly visible to the north. Ben Vorlich and Stuc a Chroin were very prominent and surprisingly snowy to the south.
Vorlich to the south?
The ridge walk over to Meall Garbh was a delight. The descent from Meall Garbh was quite spicy though. If I do this ridge again I think I’d prefer to do it clockwise as this section would certainly be easier in ascent. On Beinn nan Eachan I lay on my back on the soft, grassy summit and just soaked up the rays. Some sun cream would have been handy though. I’m sure I wasn’t the only walker caught out this weekend by the sublime, spring like conditions. Wanting to save my legs for Tower Ridge I omitted Creag na Callich and was back at my car exactly 5 hours after my start.
Day 2 // Sunday 20 March 2016 // Tower Ridge, Ben Nevis // 11.3km // 7hr 42min // 1151m ascent
The alarm clock sounded at 5am but adrenaline ensured I was already awake. I had fuelled up the afternoon before, with a monstrously large meal at the Real Food Cafe. By 6am I was on the road. The sun rose en route, casting a beautiful pink glow over the big Buachaille on my way into Glencoe. It would have been nice to stop and enjoy the sunrise but today I was on a mission. I met Max Hunter, my guide for the day, at the gondola car park at 7.15am. We jumped into Max’s van and made our way up to the forestry car park. The track to this car park is gated but most of the local guides have a key. At 270m it gives a useful head start to anyone heading up towards the CIC hut. I’ve done the trudge from the North face car park before and was glad not to have to do it today.
Early morning walk in
We knew that some of the teams ahead of us along the Allt A Mhuilinn would be heading for Tower Ridge as well. Max had stressed the importance of speed of movement today. Some of the crux sections are quite high up where overtaking is impossible. Not wanting to shiver for hours high on the ridge behind teams crossing those cruxes slowly we set a blistering pace towards the CIC hut which we reached in under an hour. We took a good drink from the water pipe by the hut then left only a little water in our bottles, wanting to keep weight to a minimum. We would be able to refill at a waterfall on our descent and were not planning to stop for refreshment at any point on the ridge itself.
Coire na Ciste from the CIC Hut
Setting off - team ahead in the gully
Setting off we saw two teams already on the ridge and another just in front of us, heading for the gully to the east of the Douglas boulder. We also gained the ridge from the east but snuck round in front of the team in the gully via a short cut that gave us an early advantage. The lower stages of the ridge were pretty straightforward and we moved quickly towards the Little Tower. Although we had a 50 metre rope, most of it stayed coiled. Max’s approach was to split the route into a larger number of much shorter pitches, often using natural protection (looping the rope around rocks) on the least exposed sections along with a mixture of nuts, friends and hexes when required. I’m sure this approach contributed to our speed of movement. We certainly seemed to be moving more quickly than other teams using the full length of their ropes.
Max protecting the route
We overtook the second team before the Little Tower and would then have the rest of the ridge to ourselves (the third team on the ridge was far ahead of us). Soon we were rounding the magnificently exposed Eastern Traverse. Hundreds of metres below us to the left we could see several teams of climbers on different routes in Coire Leis. These little black specks against the snow gave me an appreciation of the sheer scale of Ben Nevis. What an awe inspiring mountain!
3 climbers visible in this photo!
Climbers in Coire Leis
Beyond the Great Tower we faced the day’s true crux - Tower Gap. Benightments are not uncommon here but this is really not a place you would want to linger. Fortunate in having such an experienced leader (Max knows the ridge like the back of his hand) we were able to navigate this important obstacle reasonably efficiently - only my nerves slowed the pace at this point. Max explained clearly, hold by hold, how I would cross the gap. However, the exposure is simply massive and actually crossing the gap is as much a psychological test as a physical one.
Approaching Tower Gap
First one has to down climb awkwardly to a very slender perch. I was pleased that I managed to do this without having to put my weight on the rope - a fall here would be all too easy. I was balanced very delicately on crampon points with hundreds of metres of air dropping away behind and beneath me. At the gap itself, there are a couple of ropes slung around a rock pillar. After placing our own protection it was possible to grab this fixed rope with one hand, then lean out into the gap with the other and grab a hold on the far side before swinging one leg over and then completing the move. Max crossed before me then moved along out of sight to place protection and to belay me when I crossed. Knowing that a fall would just mean going for an awkward dangle, rather than plunging hundreds of metres didn’t make it any easier to actually cross the gap.
Don't look down!
Looking down into the snowy abyss I faced a moment of panic and thought to myself, “God this is terrifying, what on earth am I doing here?” Instantly I realised there was no way but forwards and decided to go for it. The moment I moved I called loudly to Max “Tight, tight!” and I felt the rope tighten as I made it cleanly and safely to the other side. The dose of adrenaline was incredible and I had to stop for just a moment to catch my breath. This was without question the most difficult and terrifying move I have had to perform on a mountain. The Inaccessible Pinnacle is a cake walk by comparison. The sensation I felt at the point of starting the move is, I imagine, similar to that experienced by someone about to hurl themselves from an aircraft wearing a parachute.
With the day’s real difficulties behind us we moved swiftly along the final sections of the ridge and before long found ourselves on the plateau. In no time at all I was standing at the summit trig point and contemplating my achievement. In January 2014 it had been a disappointment not to make it onto the CMD arete and even though I’ve stood atop Snowdon, Scafell Pike, Carrauntuohil and Slieve Donard - the Ben had so far eluded me. Now I had made it, and via such an exciting route. What’s more, I really seem to have bounced back from my injuries of a year ago. Patience, persistence, stretching and physio (as well as well timed doses of rest) have worked wonders for me and I’m sure that they can for anyone else whose enjoyment of the hills has been hampered by injury.
Ben Nevis summit - the best view in Scotland?
Success! Big thanks to Max Hunter
Having made such good time across Tower Ridge we discussed the possibility of a descent via Ledge Route. I think that I might have had it in my legs to do this but I didn’t want to push things so we began our descent by the red burn instead. Near its base we passed an impressive waterfall where we took a good drink. I refilled my bottle completely after drinking and carried the litre of Nevis water back in my checked luggage the following day. I now have a some in my crystal jug next to my whiskey and the rest in my fridge. What a treat to enjoy mountain water with my drink instead of the awful stuff that comes out of the tap in London.
Brief sunshine on the descent
Tastes better than Thames water in your Talisker
My impression of the mountain on descent was so different from the climb. I was surprised how expansive the summit plateau and while our route down was convenient it was far less interesting. Almost like a different mountain when compared with anything on the north side. For the three peak challengers, the ascent of the Ben must be a fairly dull trudge.
With two great mountaineering routes under my belt in the space of a month I am now very keen to sample the alpine environment. A year ago I was completely focused on the munros and was in a desperate hurry to work through them as quickly as possible. Today I feel quite different. Climbing all the munros remains my objective but I’m no longer in such a rush. It may take decades and perhaps all the better for me if it does. In the meantime I really want to focus on the quality of my mountain days as much as the quantity of summits ticked and as I spend more time on a rope, it whets my appetite for similarly testing routes - whether that’s on the rocks of Snowdonia, up in Scotland or maybe further afield.
PTARMIGAN.GPX Open full screen NB: Walkhighlands is not responsible for the accuracy of gpx files in users posts
TOWER RIDGE.GPX Open full screen NB: Walkhighlands is not responsible for the accuracy of gpx files in users posts
by Fife Flyer » Fri Mar 25, 2016 8:09 pm
The photo's are superb, I'll stick to walking rather than climbing
by wilkiemurray » Fri Mar 25, 2016 8:17 pm
- Posts: 1332
- Joined: Jan 26, 2012
- Location: Perthshire
by jenniferc6 » Sat Mar 26, 2016 10:59 am
by Alteknacker » Sat Mar 26, 2016 12:57 pm
I had both Tower Ridge and Meall nan Tarmachan in mind for last year, but dropped the former because I was thinking of doing it in combination with some other hills, and thought it would take too long; and the latter because I'd got it planned for the end of a walk, and it got a bit late in the evening.
BTW did you consider starting via the Douglas Boulder? This is what I have in mind at the moment....
by Guinessman » Sat Mar 26, 2016 4:45 pm
by Riverman » Sat Mar 26, 2016 8:00 pm
Walkhighlands community forum is advert free
Can you help support Walkhighlands and the online community by donating by direct debit?