free to be able to rate and comment on reports (as well as access 1:25000 mapping).
Being contrary I decided to do the route in reverse from how it is described here. Started from just South of Johnscleugh, where the Herring Road meets the B6355. Lots of parking there. I followed the Herring Road up the hill - its recently been remade using rubble and this makes for not an easy walk - its a bit like walking up scree on the initial steep section.
- The Herring Road
After a while it reverts back to a grassy track which makes for easy walking - the path to the top of Spartleton veers off to the right through a gate and its a straightforward walk to the cairn and trig point along a track that changes back into a rubble road just before the top. The views from the top are tremendous - 360-degree and today I could see as far as Holy Island to the South, Dumyat to the West and the Sidlaw Hills and beyond to the North, whilst not forgetting the Forth, Bass Rock and the Isle of May. Plus of course lots of wind turbines!
I headed South West from the summit, following the rubble track. Soon this started to run off towards the South East, and I could see that I needed to get down towards Gamelshiel Castle for the return.
However I could not find the path described here so I cut straight down through the heather to the fence-line that is supposed to mark the track (but I still could'nt see it!) However I did find Gamelshiel Castle and the path from there back down the valley is very clear.
Once down in the valley I turned North and headed back following the river on an easy if muddy track back to the car.
A good walk - apart from the rubble road. Did not see a soul all day. I was glad of my new Scarpa boots and my poles - oh and needed my fleecy hat on the top of the hill it was quite autumnal in the stiff breeze. The Lammermuir Hills are superb in this weather - quiet and a really peaceful place.