by Mal Grey » Thu Jan 21, 2021 9:12 pm
Useful and indeed pretty comprehensive. Would definitely help somebody trying to work out which general design might work for them. I guess some of the examples you give will change and be replaced, but its a great starting point and maybe you can update those.
Some further feedback on "Y-Hub" designs, as you mentioned. I've a Luxe Outdoor Habitat with a full mesh inner, which is basically a Hubba Hubba copy.
The pros are; internal space for weight is good, freestanding, very quick to erect, good porch space.
The cons are; performance in the wind is definitely not the strong point. I've had it out in 60mph gusts and at that point it was turning inside out on my face, but survived with a bent pole. However even in 20-30mph winds, the struts above the porch tend to push inwards quite a bit and a lack of guys doesn't help. Flysheet is cut for warmer climates so a bit draughty. Just about 3 season.
It is, though, my favourite tent to spend time in. That's because its a freestanding mesh inner, and in summer I just use that, or have both flysheet porches tied right back.
As to whether you've "missed any" designs, there's maybe an argument for a sub-category of single trekking-pole tents that are much more advanced than the traditional pyramid. I have a Six Moon Design Lunar Solo which is an example of those. Fully sealed, with a mesh inner door and porch, but otherwise single skin. I think they're a good option for proper lightweight trips and it certainly withstands wind well. Have only tried it for a few nights so far though.