Share your personal walking route experiences in Scotland, and comment on other peoples' reports.
Warning
Please note that hillwalking when there is snow lying requires an ice-axe, crampons and the knowledge, experience and skill to use them correctly. Summer routes may not be viable or appropriate in winter. See winter information on our skills and safety pages for more information.
Creag Mhor & Beinn Heasgarnich
Creag Mhor & Beinn Heasgarnich
by jimandandrea » Thu Feb 17, 2011 9:33 am
Route description: Creag Mhor and Beinn Heasgarnich
Munros included on this walk: Beinn Heasgarnich, Creag Mhor (Glen Lochay)
Date walked: 10/02/2011
Time taken: 9.5 hours
Distance: 25.3 km
Ascent: 1225m
2 people think this report is great. Register or Login free to be able to rate and comment on reports (as well as access 1:25000 mapping).In anticipation that this was going to be an epic for us and that we would spend most (all) of our daylight hours walking we thought it best that we set more than one alarm. The second one did it, and as we parted the curtains it was with some optimism that we felt the darkness above was in fact clear. By the time the flask was made, the porridge consumed, the car loaded with everything we could possibly need we were off in the darkness leaving our compact and bijou cottage in Killin and up Glen Lochay eventually reaching our start point at Kenknock. Actually, it would have been good to head up the track from there and park at the upper track but alas my car was not of the 'off road' variety and was not willing to inflict serious damage in pursuit of saving us 15 mins of walking. As we parked the skies were filling with the morning light and and the few heavy grey clouds were going away to annoy someone else.
It isn't really very clear where you should park in order to be out of the Farmers (and other land users) way so we left it where we felt it was a 'least inconvenient to others' spot. We were off along the valley bottom and although the sun had not actually got to us yet we were resolved that it soon would. Its just over 3 miles along this valley bottom and you can make good time if there is no wind, the sun is in the sky and the ambiance is generally pleasant.
We opted not to do this as we were too busy taking pictures, admiring the coo’s, the scenery and the approaching Ben Challum, but eventually we made it to Batavaine. The route takes you up behind the house, up the grassy slope to join the track that makes its way up to connect to the upper track.
Now that was the easy bit, which we soon realised as we headed up the grassy slope towards Sron nan Eun. Now here’s the thing, the route as detailed in ‘The Ultimate Guide’ details a route around its base however somewhere in the plethora of guide books we recalled one that suggested an option of cutting a diagonal right to approach the summit. This we duly did and had an excellent rise to the top. Excellent snow with unbelievable views that were sublime.
Although there was snow it was quite clear from the little patched of path we could see the route up to the summit of Creag Mhor (1048m).
Top reached the scenery was amazing. Great place for a cup of tea and a butty.
Although it is clear where you want to go – alas its not so straightforward.
Again the guidebooks suggest a route that is NW for ½ Km then North…. Hmm!
The snow was rock set with ice and the traverse NW was somewhat precarious – I would suggest following the walking NW to avoid this guidance. Should the visibility been poor and were unable to see where we were heading – it could have been rather dodgy the next bit. Not so today thank goodness with excellent visability what was required of us was clear and obvious.
Reaching the col and crossing some boggy stuff we looked back at Creag Mhor just confirm that heading off in the opposite direction at the top was so the right thing to do. From Lochan na Baintighearna we made our way across to ascend the ridge taking us to the top of Stob an Fhir-bhogha (1029m).
From here it seemed like a stones throw to Beinn Heasgarnich - aye maybe if I was Fingal as it took longer to get there than it looked. The good thing was that as we made our way across we spotted an excellent escape route that we would take on our return back to the track. From Heasgarnich we could see Ben Nevis and Ben Cruachan indeed I think we could just make out Disneyland, Florida (OK, maybe the fair was in Oban).
I would just like to add that both summits were very icy with mainly a thin or hard cover of snow over rock. Having packed microspikes I was damn well going to use them and we did making the going not just easier and safer but it also allowed us to gape at the inspiring views that surrounded us.
Now, we still have about 2 miles to go but the light falling behind Challum made it a pleasant plod back to the car.
OK it was a long day and OK my legs were more than a little tired and OK maybe I wasn't upset that it was not as good the next day and I could get a wee lie in (OK - that's a lie - I enjoyed the extra kip) however it was a grand day out.
This is our first walk write up which has made me appreciate the work that others go to in order to get their day typed out - respect! Maybe I will ge faster at it.... maybe.
PS I have no idea why I had the extra/repeat pic at the bottom - could not get rid. Hey ho.
It isn't really very clear where you should park in order to be out of the Farmers (and other land users) way so we left it where we felt it was a 'least inconvenient to others' spot. We were off along the valley bottom and although the sun had not actually got to us yet we were resolved that it soon would. Its just over 3 miles along this valley bottom and you can make good time if there is no wind, the sun is in the sky and the ambiance is generally pleasant.
We opted not to do this as we were too busy taking pictures, admiring the coo’s, the scenery and the approaching Ben Challum, but eventually we made it to Batavaine. The route takes you up behind the house, up the grassy slope to join the track that makes its way up to connect to the upper track.
Now that was the easy bit, which we soon realised as we headed up the grassy slope towards Sron nan Eun. Now here’s the thing, the route as detailed in ‘The Ultimate Guide’ details a route around its base however somewhere in the plethora of guide books we recalled one that suggested an option of cutting a diagonal right to approach the summit. This we duly did and had an excellent rise to the top. Excellent snow with unbelievable views that were sublime.
Although there was snow it was quite clear from the little patched of path we could see the route up to the summit of Creag Mhor (1048m).
Top reached the scenery was amazing. Great place for a cup of tea and a butty.
Although it is clear where you want to go – alas its not so straightforward.
Again the guidebooks suggest a route that is NW for ½ Km then North…. Hmm!
The snow was rock set with ice and the traverse NW was somewhat precarious – I would suggest following the walking NW to avoid this guidance. Should the visibility been poor and were unable to see where we were heading – it could have been rather dodgy the next bit. Not so today thank goodness with excellent visability what was required of us was clear and obvious.
Reaching the col and crossing some boggy stuff we looked back at Creag Mhor just confirm that heading off in the opposite direction at the top was so the right thing to do. From Lochan na Baintighearna we made our way across to ascend the ridge taking us to the top of Stob an Fhir-bhogha (1029m).
From here it seemed like a stones throw to Beinn Heasgarnich - aye maybe if I was Fingal as it took longer to get there than it looked. The good thing was that as we made our way across we spotted an excellent escape route that we would take on our return back to the track. From Heasgarnich we could see Ben Nevis and Ben Cruachan indeed I think we could just make out Disneyland, Florida (OK, maybe the fair was in Oban).
I would just like to add that both summits were very icy with mainly a thin or hard cover of snow over rock. Having packed microspikes I was damn well going to use them and we did making the going not just easier and safer but it also allowed us to gape at the inspiring views that surrounded us.
Now, we still have about 2 miles to go but the light falling behind Challum made it a pleasant plod back to the car.
OK it was a long day and OK my legs were more than a little tired and OK maybe I wasn't upset that it was not as good the next day and I could get a wee lie in (OK - that's a lie - I enjoyed the extra kip) however it was a grand day out.
This is our first walk write up which has made me appreciate the work that others go to in order to get their day typed out - respect! Maybe I will ge faster at it.... maybe.
PS I have no idea why I had the extra/repeat pic at the bottom - could not get rid. Hey ho.
- Attachments
-
- Sun going down over Ben Challum
Last edited by jimandandrea on Thu Feb 17, 2011 11:19 am, edited 2 times in total.
-
jimandandrea - Munro compleatist
- Posts: 339
- Munros:264 Corbetts:6
- Hewitts:98
- Wainwrights:214
- Joined: Mar 6, 2010
- Location: Kendal Cumbria
Re: Creag Mhor & Beinn Heasgarnich
by Graeme D » Thu Feb 17, 2011 10:09 am
Brilliant report which I thoroughly drooled over! Love the pictures too, especially the second one (relection shot) and the "path looking up to summit of Creag Mhor".
I guess you somehow accidentally added that last photograph twice but one time you didn't place it inline in the body of the report.

Re: Creag Mhor & Beinn Heasgarnich
by Paul Webster » Thu Feb 17, 2011 10:15 am
Wow - absolutely superb report. Welcome to Walkhighlands!
I'm especially impressed as my memory of those hills was not very inspiring (probably partly the weather) but they look wonderful in your photos
I'm especially impressed as my memory of those hills was not very inspiring (probably partly the weather) but they look wonderful in your photos

-
Paul Webster - Site Admin
- Mountain Walker
- Posts: 5349
- Munros:282 Corbetts:222
- Grahams:66 Donalds:43
- Sub 2000:116 Hewitts:133
- Wainwrights:134 Islands:92
- Joined: Jan 6, 2007
- Location: Highland
- Walk wish-list
Re: Creag Mhor & Beinn Heasgarnich
by rockhopper » Thu Feb 17, 2011 2:11 pm
Lovely first report and pictures - I especially like the photo titled "On the nose of Stron nan Eun looking down Glen Lochay and onto Tarmachan".
) a few weeks ago with white out conditions and rotten weather so it's great to see what they look like in decent weather (and a decent photographer). 

I'd echo Paul's comments. I did this trip anticlockwise (I seem to prefer it to clockwisePaul Webster wrote:Wow - absolutely superb report. Welcome to Walkhighlands!
I'm especially impressed as my memory of those hills was not very inspiring (probably partly the weather) but they look wonderful in your photos


Re: Creag Mhor & Beinn Heasgarnich
by gammy leg walker » Thu Feb 17, 2011 3:28 pm
Really good first WR,and pictures,still not done those two
-
gammy leg walker - Mountaineer
- Posts: 3349
- Munros:262 Corbetts:7
- Grahams:4 Donalds:3
- Sub 2000:2
- Islands:7
- Joined: Jan 30, 2010
- Location: Central Region
- Walk wish-list
Re: Creag Mhor & Beinn Heasgarnich
by doogz » Thu Feb 17, 2011 6:27 pm
Beautiful shots
We were on beinn ime with views to your hills
Did you need crampons for the descent of Creag Mhor ?
Looked decidedly icy ......especially in the shade
Only the summit of Ime was icy
Never saw a thing when I done these , thanks for filling in the views
Doogz
We were on beinn ime with views to your hills
Did you need crampons for the descent of Creag Mhor ?
Looked decidedly icy ......especially in the shade
Only the summit of Ime was icy
Never saw a thing when I done these , thanks for filling in the views

Doogz
- doogz
- Posts: 449
- Joined: Sep 17, 2008
Re: Creag Mhor & Beinn Heasgarnich
by jimandandrea » Fri Feb 18, 2011 9:11 am
We did use crampons on Creag Mhor but ice was the issue on Heasgarnich so we used microspikes there - which were excellent. We now pack both as ice has been more of an issue for us this winter and great when you need to 'get a grip'. Cheers for the feedback.
How do you post your pics without also posting the details of the file etc? I see other people manage this but I can't see how to do it.
How do you post your pics without also posting the details of the file etc? I see other people manage this but I can't see how to do it.
-
jimandandrea - Munro compleatist
- Posts: 339
- Munros:264 Corbetts:6
- Hewitts:98
- Wainwrights:214
- Joined: Mar 6, 2010
- Location: Kendal Cumbria
Re: Creag Mhor & Beinn Heasgarnich
by Paul Webster » Fri Feb 18, 2011 9:50 am
How do you post your pics without also posting the details of the file etc? I see other people manage this but I can't see how to do it.
Those ones are where the poster has hosted the photo on another website and just shows it on Walkhighlands. I could easily remove the file details from the display if you think that would look better (but leave the caption)?
-
Paul Webster - Site Admin
- Mountain Walker
- Posts: 5349
- Munros:282 Corbetts:222
- Grahams:66 Donalds:43
- Sub 2000:116 Hewitts:133
- Wainwrights:134 Islands:92
- Joined: Jan 6, 2007
- Location: Highland
- Walk wish-list
Re: Creag Mhor & Beinn Heasgarnich
by jimandandrea » Fri Feb 18, 2011 9:55 am
No- you have answered a question that puzzled me as I noticed on some postings - there was nothing underneath and wondered how they did that? No, just leave the file name - I will just have to avoid using incorrect spellings etc when I name my files (as I often do!). Cheers.
-
jimandandrea - Munro compleatist
- Posts: 339
- Munros:264 Corbetts:6
- Hewitts:98
- Wainwrights:214
- Joined: Mar 6, 2010
- Location: Kendal Cumbria
Re: Creag Mhor & Beinn Heasgarnich
by ChrisW » Fri Feb 18, 2011 8:59 pm
Really great report and stunning pics, I enjoyed reading this, thanks for posting 

Re: Creag Mhor & Beinn Heasgarnich
by jimandandrea » Sat Feb 19, 2011 10:34 am
rockhopper wrote:Lovely first report and pictures - I especially like the photo titled "On the nose of Stron nan Eun looking down Glen Lochay and onto Tarmachan".
I'd echo Paul's comments. I did this trip anticlockwise (I seem to prefer it to clockwisePaul Webster wrote:Wow - absolutely superb report. Welcome to Walkhighlands!
I'm especially impressed as my memory of those hills was not very inspiring (probably partly the weather) but they look wonderful in your photos) a few weeks ago with white out conditions and rotten weather so it's great to see what they look like in decent weather (and a decent photographer).
We opted to do it clockwise because of your report - mainly due to your descent description. We commented at regular intervals on your walk vs our day. Well done you for doing it in those conditions

-
jimandandrea - Munro compleatist
- Posts: 339
- Munros:264 Corbetts:6
- Hewitts:98
- Wainwrights:214
- Joined: Mar 6, 2010
- Location: Kendal Cumbria
Re: Creag Mhor & Beinn Heasgarnich
by kevsbald » Sat Feb 19, 2011 4:37 pm
I think these two hills are under-rated and your report does them great justice. Welcome to the site.
2 people think this report is great. Register or Login free to be able to rate and comment on reports (as well as access 1:25000 mapping).
13 posts
• Page 1 of 1
Walkhighlands community forum is advert free
Can you help support Walkhighlands and the online community by donating by direct debit?