walkhighlands

Wellies desperately needed on Wellington hill!

Sub 2000s: Càrn Garbh

Date walked: 24/05/2021

Time taken: 8.5 hours

Distance: 20.5km

Ascent: 853m

Our second day of Glen Loth wreck hunting started with serious doubts whether we'd be able to do anything at all. Weather in the morning was absolutely c**p. We drove up north in pouring rain, hoping that we might leave the cloud behind us, but when we arrived in Glen Loth, we still had to wait nearly half an hour in the car until weather showed the first signs of getting better. Our intended route for today was the circuit of Càrn Garbh (aka Wellington Hill) and Col-Bheinn, including Glen Sletdale and two plane crash sites, starting from the hydro dam on Loth Burn.
Route intended (and recommended):

carn_garbh.gpx Open full screen  NB: Walkhighlands is not responsible for the accuracy of gpx files in users posts


Unfortunately, we had to change our plans and adjust the route because after the heavy downpour, Sletdale Burn transferred into Sletdale Torrent and there was absolutely no chance of crossing it at any point.
2021-05-25 carn garbh 060.JPG
Sletdale Burn photographed from the bridge at the bottom of Creag Riabhach

We ended up doing a T-shaped walk, involving a lot of bog-hopping and peat hag crossing - a true splogathon, as Kevin calls it. This option is a last resort when rivers are in spate. We still managed to visit both crash sites and claim the Sub'2 Marylin, but I'd definitely NOT recommend crossing the ridge between Col-Bheinn and Creag a'Chrionaich twice!

Track_CARN GARBH 20.5 KM.gpx Open full screen  NB: Walkhighlands is not responsible for the accuracy of gpx files in users posts


Originally, we wanted to use a good track into Glen Sletdale, but now we had to stay on the southern side of the burn, we thought, just as well we head straight up!
Good luck crossing this!
2021-05-25 carn garbh 067.JPG

Instead of climbing up Creag Riabhach and traversing Cnoc na h-Iolaire, we opted to go straight up the middle shoulder, Creag a'Chrionaich:
2021-05-25 carn garbh 069.JPG

Having crossed Allt a'Chrionaich and marched over some squelchy ground at the bottom of the corrie, we actually found the slopes of Creag a'Chrionaich quite easy and relatively dry. So far, so good:
2021-05-25 carn garbh 005.JPG

Weather was improving (at least it stopped raining!) and the cloud was slowly lifting of Beinn Dhorainn. We were not that fussy about views today; we took enough photos of Caithness hills the day before. Today was all about the two crash sites: both were far more remote than the previous two targets!
2021-05-25 carn garbh 001.JPG
Beinn Dhorainn from Creag a'Chrionaich

The eastern cliffs of Càrn Garbh seen from across Glen Sletdale. Such a shame we couldn't see and photograph them from closer proximity. Our original route goes up the narrow glen on the left hand side:
2021-05-25 carn garbh 013.JPG

On the top of Creag a'Chrionaich we came across a boggy ATV track which we followed for some time, but soon it turned into a muddy stream, so we gave up and simply hiked across the waterlogged ground to the next top (457m, not named on any maps). By now, we were already used to the lovely sound of our boots getting sucked into the soggy ground.
Gloomp!
Squelch!
Splash!
:sick: :sick: :sick:
I should have brought my kayak!
On the next col (428m) we found a set of strange machinery. Aliens watching us?...
2021-05-25 carn garbh 019.JPG
Cloud monitoring station

We plodded on to the next unnamed top (505m) where we located another ATV track. It wasn't of much help though...
2021-05-25 carn garbh 028.JPG

The Armageddon sky to the south of us:
2021-05-25 carn garbh 029.JPG

From the 505m top we turned north, following the wide ridge towards Càrn Garbh. We encountered more bog and peat hags but at least weather was now looking reasonable.
The first crash site, one of Vickers Wellington Mk.IC R1093, is situated on the NW slopes of Càrn Garbh. The easiest way to get to this spot is from Strath Brora, using the access track to Gordonbush Windfarm, but we preferred our route despite the amount of peat hag dancing we had to perform :lol:
Actually, this is where Sletdale Burn is born, in the dip between Carn Garbh and Meallan Liath Mor:
2021-05-25 carn garbh 039.JPG

With only 6 digit grid ref, we realized that we might still have to search a relatively large patch of ground, so we followed the stream into the dip and then planned to zig-zag uphill to scan the slopes. Luckily, Kevin spotted the crash site almost immediately and we climbed up to the scar:
2021-05-25 carn garbh 082.JPG

The large peat hag looks like it is plane-shaped so we were under the initial impression that this was where the Wellington hit the hill. Later, we found out that the actual impact scar is much higher up the slope and this is just where a large amount of wreckage ended up, either dumped in the hag or simply tumbled down here.
2021-05-25 carn garbh 040.JPG

In the peat hag and just below it, we found a lot of smashed up bits of aluminum, parts of geodetic frame, pipes, cables, fuselage panels, undercarriage assembly, even a wheel, complete with a tyre though flat as a pancake. We were fascinated by the wreckage and spent probably half an hour photographing every detail, trying to guess which part of the aircraft particular pieces came from.
Image2021-05-25 carn garbh 046 by Kevin Dalziel, on Flickr
The Vickers Wellington was a twin-engined long-range medium bomber, powered by two Bristol Pegasus radial engines. This particular plane was the Mark IC variant, one of 2,685 produced overall. The Mark IC had a crew of six: a pilot, radio operator, navigator/bombardier, observer/nose gunner, tail gunner and waist gunner.
2021-05-25 carn garbh 122.JPG

A key innovation of the Wellington was its geodetic construction, built from no less than 1650 elements! It was a giant puzzle of duralumin beams formed into a metal framework, fixed together by wooden battens screwed to the beams. The whole structure was then covered with Irish linen, treated with layers of dope, forming the outer skin of the aircraft. This innovative construction proved to be versatile and compatible with many adaptations like heavy all-up weight, large bombs, tropicalisation and the addition of long-range fuel tanks. Vickers Wellington was therefore used extensively during WW2. It could reach maximum speed of 235 mph (378 km/h) and their service ceiling was 18000 ft (5500 m).
Image2021-05-25 carn garbh 114 by Kevin Dalziel, on Flickr
Today, there are two complete Vickers Wellingtons still surviving in the UK, both in museums, though neither is airworthy. I have never seen a complete Vickers and probably never will, unless we decide to go on some kind of air museum tour when the COVID situation is solved (at the moment many museums are still closed or have restricted access). So sad that the only way we can get to know these legendary machines is to examine the broken and destroyed ones...
2021-05-25 carn garbh 108.JPG

Probably a part of fuel tank:
Image2021-05-25 carn garbh 124 by Kevin Dalziel, on Flickr
This particular aircraft, belonging to No. 20 OTU, set off on 30th July 1941 on a navigation training flight from the RAF base in Lossiemouth. The reasons of the accident are not known; possibly bad weather contributed to the crash? The plane flew into the north western side of Carn Garbh and collided with the slope at the height of 510m. Four crew members were killed but two (the pilot and the wireless operator) survived the crash.
2021-01-25 carn garbh 008.JPG

One of the internet sources suggests that the two engines are still on site but were buried by the recovery unit. Maybe one could locate them using a metal detector, but we are far from such silly ideas. There was enough to investigate on the surface, anyway!
2021-01-25 carn garbh 029.JPG

Close up of the tyre with the name of the producer, "Dunlop" still visible:
2021-01-25 carn garbh 039.JPG

More of the "lattice" structure of the wings:
2021-01-25 carn garbh 017.JPG

In the second peat hag, a few meters to the right (as facing the slope) we found some more wreckage:
2021-01-25 carn garbh 059.JPG

We knew this wasn't all so headed uphill, scanning the heathery ground around us. It wasn't long till we came across more...
Image2021-01-25 carn garbh 070 by Kevin Dalziel, on Flickr
... and more...
2021-05-25 carn garbh 200.JPG

...until we reached the impact zone:
Image2021-01-25 carn garbh 107 by Kevin Dalziel, on Flickr
Here, there was a mind-boggling number of small pieces to photograph, including the aircraft’s receiver from the wireless operator’s station:
2021-05-25 carn garbh 268.JPG

Burnt-out battery:
Image2021-01-25 carn garbh 134 by Kevin Dalziel, on Flickr
The second undercarriage assembly:
Image2021-05-25 carn garbh 254 by Kevin Dalziel, on Flickr
Burst oxygen bottle:
Image2021-01-25 carn garbh 108 by Kevin Dalziel, on Flickr
Not sure about this part, a section of fuel tank perhaps?
Image2021-05-25 carn garbh 210 by Kevin Dalziel, on Flickr
Looking down the NW slopes of Carn Garbh from the crash site, Gordonbush Windfarm on the horizon:
Image2021-01-25 carn garbh 153 by Kevin Dalziel, on Flickr
Again, we lost far too much time photographing all the little details of the accident site...
2021-01-25 carn garbh 076.JPG

...so by the time we eventually left the Vickers Wellington behind and walked the short distance to the summit of Carn Garbh, it was already half past two.
Lucy on the summit. There is no cairn, but a tuft of moss marks the highest spot:
Image2021-01-25 carn garbh 166 by Kevin Dalziel, on Flickr
With no time to faff about, we had a quick snack bar and headed back to the 505m top, over the ocean of squelchy grass, moss & heather, over the countless peat hags and muddy puddles. By now, we were seriously fed up with the splogathon we had to endure, but since we were already here, just as well, we wanted to visit the second crash site.
2021-01-25 carn garbh 179.JPG
Barracuda, here we come!

Conditions have improved since early morning:
2021-05-25 carn garbh 297.JPG

We descended the 505m top and aimed south for Col Bheinn, over another peat-haggy bealach. The top of Col-Bheinn proved a good viewpoint. It has a trig point (visible in the photo below to the right):
2021-01-25 carn garbh 190.JPG

...but the true summit (according to Kevin's GPS) is about 50m to the west, no cairn marking the exact spot.
2021-05-25 carn garbh 305.JPG
A summit like many others...

Posing with the Gordonbush Windfarm in the background:
2021-01-25 carn garbh 191.JPG

The second crash site we were looking for today is located on the southern slopes of Col-Bheinn, about 70m below the summit. We couldn't see it from above but had a six-digit grid ref so headed in the direction our GPS was suggesting:
2021-05-25 carn garbh 307.JPG

We found the Barracuda very quickly. The biggest feature of this crash site are no doubt the wings of the aircraft, still connected by the center section:
2021-05-25 carn garbh 342.JPG

Next to the wreckage, a small memorial plaque was placed, giving the names of the three crew who lost their lives here:
2021-05-25 carn garbh 309.JPG

I was already emotional after seeing the carnage on the Wellington Hill, now the simple message on this little board really hit the spot. The three lads who died here in 1945 were so young. 19-20 years old, come on! Just kids, for heaven's sake. YOUNG KIDS who had their whole life to live, jobs to work, girls to marry, families to raise, houses to build. And they ended up dead on this remote slope. Why??? Because one greedy man with a small moustache had a bad attitude :twisted:
2021-01-25 carn garbh 193.JPG

There is very little info available about this particular accident. According to "Aircraft Wrecks: The Walker's Guide", the crew were flying from RNAS Fearn, HMS Owl, near Tain when they flew into the southern side of Col-bheinn. Perhaps it was just a navigational error (they were just trainees after all) or maybe the cloud obscuring the view contributed to the crash. Sadly, we will never know.
2021-05-25 carn garbh 312.JPG

The Fairey Barracuda was another ingenue design, a British carrier-borne torpedo and dive bomber, the first aircraft of this type operated by the Royal Navy's Fleet Air Arm to be fabricated entirely from metal. For storage, the wings folded back horizontally at the roots. Powered by one Rolls-Royce Merlin 32 V-12 liquid-cooled piston engine, the Barracudas were extensively used during the WW2 in the operations over the Atlantic Ocean, Mediterranean Sea and the Pacific Ocean against the German, Italian and Japanese forces respectively. Often they flew from aircraft carriers. They took part in the famous attack on the German battleship Tirpitz on 3 April 1944.
2021-05-25 carn garbh 322.JPG

Sadly, not a single complete Barracuda survives till today, but if you are interested in aviation, you can read more about The Barracuda Project in the Fleet Air Arm Museum HERE.
2021-05-25 carn garbh 345.JPG

An armour plate:
2021-05-25 carn garbh 325.JPG

Small details of the surviving wing structure:
2021-05-25 carn garbh 314.JPG

2021-01-25 carn garbh 195.JPG

Modern graffiti on the wing flap. Of course, there are always idiots who think that scratching their names on a war memorial is funny! :evil:
2021-05-25 carn garbh 328.JPG

Small pieces of the plane in the nearby peat hag:
Image2021-01-25 carn garbh 216 by Kevin Dalziel, on Flickr
To return to the starting point, we had a long way to hike across the peat hag hell, so we didn't waste any more time:
Image2021-01-25 carn garbh 223 by Kevin Dalziel, on Flickr
We took a shortcut crossing another boggy corrie and returned over the 457m top to Creag a'Chrionaich. From here, we still had another wet glen to negotiate before we could pick the ATV track on Creag Riabhach. Luckily, weather held on for the rest of the afternoon.
Creag Riabhach and Beinn Mhealaich from Creag a'Chrionaich:
Image2021-01-25 carn garbh 232 by Kevin Dalziel, on Flickr
One could ask why we bother. Hard to answer this. I don't want to say that we visit the crash sites for pure entertainment value, though looking for them is a kind of adventure in itself. I find these sites fascinating but also deeply disturbing. At the same time, I'm so thankful to the young, brave men who sacrificed their lives during the big conflict. Telling the stories of the crashes is just a way to remember. We owe these lost boys at least as much.

In my next report we will take a break from Panther's Aircraft Investigations and climb a remote Graham with a chance of cheesecake. TR to come soon.

Bibliography:
Internet sources:
https://www.peakdistrictaircrashes.co.uk/crash_sites/scotland/vickers-wellington-r1093-carn-garbh/
https://her.highland.gov.uk/monument/MHG30819
http://www.wtdwhd.co.uk/CC18/Day8-9.html
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vickers_Wellington
https://her.highland.gov.uk/monument/MHG30842
http://www.wtdwhd.co.uk/CC18/Day7.html
https://www.peakdistrictaircrashes.co.uk/crash_sites/scotland/fairey-barracuda-pm870-col-bheinn/
http://www.scottishhills.com/html/modules.php?name=Forums&file=viewtopic&t=1633
https://www.fleetairarm.com/barracuda-restoration-project.aspx
Books:
1. Aircraft Wrecks: The Walker's Guide: Historic Crash Sites on the Moors and Mountains of the British Isles. (2009)
by Nick Wotherspoon, Alan Clark and Mark Sheldon
2. Wrecks & Relics: 27th edition: The Indispensable Guide to Britain's Aviation Heritage (2020)
by Ken Ellis

Click to mark this as a great report. Register or Login
free to be able to rate and comment on reports (as well as access 1:25000 mapping).

Comments: 1



The rain in the glen is the mountain mourning for them

Attachment(s) Sub 2000s: Beinn Mhealaich
Date walked: 23/05/2021
Distance: 13.8km
Ascent: 616m
Comments: 2
Views: 190


Up and down the watershed

Attachment(s) Grahams: Creag Ghuanach
Date walked: 22/05/2021
Distance: 27km
Ascent: 902m
Views: 71


Another Fish(erfield) to fry

Attachment(s) Grahams: Meall Mheinnidh
Date walked: 15/05/2021
Distance: 29km
Ascent: 906m
Comments: 4
Views: 240


Can you believe it's not Costa del Sol?

Attachment(s) Sub 2000s: An Cuaidh
Date walked: 02/05/2021
Distance: 17.6km
Ascent: 360m
Comments: 2
Views: 215


Good day in Bad-rallach

Attachment(s) Grahams: Beinn Ghobhlach
Date walked: 01/05/2021
Distance: 12.9km
Ascent: 797m
Views: 93


Panther's sanctuary

Attachment(s) Grahams: Creag Dhubh Mhor
Date walked: 30/04/2021
Distance: 14.5km
Ascent: 726m
Comments: 4
Views: 354


The shape of water

Attachment(s) Grahams: Sgùrr a'Gharaidh
Date walked: 29/04/2021
Distance: 14.4km
Ascent: 883m
Views: 210


Beinn nan Imirean: pleasant surprise

Attachment(s) Corbetts: Beinn nan Imirean
Date walked: 28/04/2021
Distance: 11.9km
Ascent: 703m
Views: 195


Black Panther does Voodoo

Attachment(s) Date walked: 27/04/2021
Distance: 8.3km
Ascent: 583m
Comments: 1
Views: 148

BlackPanther


User avatar
Location: Beauly, Inverness-shire
Interests: Hillwalking, cycling, jogging, mushroom picking and many other outdoor activities, meowing on mountain summits included :P
Activity: Mountain Walker
Mountain: Beinn Eighe
Place: Isle of Skye
Gear: well... my husband ;)))
Camera: FujiFilm Finepix HS10
Ideal day out: Anything - from beach strolls to scrambling up icy slopes. Just bring it on!
Ambition: Tick off all Munros...

Munros: 260
Corbetts: 169
Grahams: 119
Sub 2000: 55
Long Distance routes: Dava Way    Moray Coastal Trail   



Filter reports


Statistics

2021

Trips: 31
Distance: 539.6 km
Ascent: 21743m
Munros: 5
Corbetts: 4
Grahams: 12
Sub2000s: 6

2020

Trips: 56
Distance: 929.5 km
Ascent: 37157m
Munros: 11
Corbetts: 12
Grahams: 10
Sub2000s: 10

2019

Trips: 68
Distance: 1137.3 km
Ascent: 57105m
Munros: 28
Corbetts: 32
Grahams: 15
Sub2000s: 4

2018

Trips: 72
Distance: 1239.15 km
Ascent: 65343m
Munros: 42
Corbetts: 21
Grahams: 27
Sub2000s: 17

2017

Trips: 60
Distance: 1128.6 km
Ascent: 55244m
Munros: 24
Corbetts: 26
Grahams: 27
Sub2000s: 6

2016

Trips: 48
Distance: 868.9 km
Ascent: 41748m
Munros: 24
Corbetts: 16
Grahams: 18
Sub2000s: 3

2015

Trips: 57
Distance: 894.2 km
Ascent: 44112m
Munros: 30
Corbetts: 25
Grahams: 16

2014

Trips: 51
Distance: 932.2 km
Ascent: 44288m
Munros: 36
Corbetts: 20
Grahams: 3
Sub2000s: 4

2013

Trips: 53
Distance: 822.6 km
Ascent: 37086m
Munros: 30
Corbetts: 17
Grahams: 5
Sub2000s: 1

2012

Trips: 76
Distance: 955.1 km
Ascent: 44087m
Munros: 37
Corbetts: 18
Grahams: 7
Sub2000s: 3

2011

Trips: 58
Distance: 645.95 km
Ascent: 30393m
Munros: 33
Corbetts: 11
Grahams: 4

2010

Trips: 17
Distance: 215.6 km
Ascent: 9756m
Munros: 4
Corbetts: 8
Grahams: 1

2009

Trips: 2
Distance: 30.9 km
Ascent: 2414m
Munros: 3

2008

Trips: 2
Distance: 35 km
Ascent: 2267m
Munros: 4


Joined: Nov 02, 2010
Last visited: Jun 17, 2021
Total posts: 3604 | Search posts