Dangers of Eaval crossing

Route: Eaval (Eabhal), North Uist

Sub 2000s: Eaval (North Uist)

Date walked: 24/08/2017

Distance: 10.5km

Please be aware that the stepping stones crossing can be very dangerous after heavy rain and at new or full moon, even when it isn't 'high tide' but generally speaking the tide is at its highest point in the month. We discovered this on our walk today and very narrowly avoided serious difficulties so I want to warn other walkers because the description does not make the dangers completely clear. Reading other reviews of the walk, it seems people have had very varied experiences of the crossing depending on the weather and, I assume, the phase of the moon. Our experience correlates most with that posted by 'AlexSkye' except we went ahead and crossed on the outward leg of the walk (not the right choice on reflection and with a little difficulty at the time but no real concerns) and then very nearly ended up in real trouble on the way back. Yesterday was very heavy rain (so the walk was very boggy throughout, not just in the first half as mentioned in the guide). Aside from this, the mountain is an enjoyable and fairly quick climb and the route and views are beautiful.

However when we got back to the stepping stones on the return leg, we encountered real problems. The guide says that the crossing may not be passable at very high tide. Despite it being well over an hour after high tide, when I tested the first couple of stepping stones, I quickly found myself in waist deep water in a fast flow. We knew the light would soon begin to fail but we had no choice but to wait to see if the tide dropped so that we could cross. In the meantime, we walked up and down to try to identify the best point to swim across, or a place to sleep for the night, if all else failed.

Eventually, half an hour later when the water level had dropped just a little, making a few of the stones visible (but most still well submerged) there was only five minutes of light left, so we decided to try to make the crossing. The alternative was wait much longer and attempt it (and the remaining walk) in complete darkness, swim, or sleep on the moor. None of these were great options so we decided to cross and made it, just, but it was difficult and dangerous and we had to do it in a very awkward and precarious crouched position, feeling below the water with our hands - almost crawling - to avoid being knocked over by the flow. We were submerged to above our waists and upper arms, grappling for slippy rocks submerged well beneath the water. We are both young and very fit, plus have lots of experience swimming in open water so we knew that if we fell in, we would likely be ok. Nonetheless, it was a sobering experience and I can well imagine that someone less steady-footed, perhaps not confident in the water, would not be able to make that crossing and would be stranded on the moor.

When we got back, we tried to calculate when would have been a good time of day to do the walk to ensure the crossing was manageable on both the way out and back and we realised that, on a day like today, there were no possible timings that would have worked to make the crossing straightforward both ways - the water levels were simply too high throughout. Please, please do not do this walk when there has been heavy rain and/or there is a new or full moon unless you are experienced and in river-crossing. Be safe!

Click to mark this as a great report. Register or Login
free to be able to rate and comment on reports (as well as access 1:25000 mapping).

Comments: 6


Activity: Walker

Filter reports



Trips: 1
Distance: 10.5 km
Sub2000s: 1

Joined: Aug 24, 2017
Last visited: Sep 09, 2018
Total posts: 2 | Search posts